Unpopular opinion

[Eliroth-Kaminari]

i have all 3 tanks on 70:

my dummy 10min parse result atm:
War 3.1k pld 2.9k drk 2.8k:
Dark still barely keep up whit pld dmg.
drk dps relay on bloodsword + delirum combo so in real fight
Drk dps rotation is 2min pld dps rotation is 1min war dps rotation is 2min.
meaning in actual fight pld will get lesser impact when boss mechanic hits into your burst rotation.
so in real fight its harder to war bring out that dps same go to drk compare to pld.

Utility side Pld is king of utility and i have seen PLD/PLD comps because of it allredy for V4
Drk TBN is good mitigation skill but only come to same lvl as war IB or PLD Shieldron.
Thinking TBN as utility is not realy true.

Defence side DRK is bottom as well because Shadow wall is unnecessarily 3min cd when its weaker version of vengeance that is 2min cd and Sentinel is 3min because extra 10% mitigation that is good when tanking in Sword oath.
LD is still biggest punishing out of 3 tank panic buttons and at end of this raid tier we have around 61k health on tanks so good bless healers who can do 6k HPS to get it off whit 10s.

Useless skill list on tanks atm
War:
Shake it off - we will see change on this.
Drk:
Dark Passenger - u need to be idiot to use it whit mp cost it has.
Sole Survivor - it come close to useful as shake it off it is good when u can use it but it find maybe use in 1 of 4 raid fights and for that it become already in ground where it should find some buff or change.
Unleash - Might as well change it to flash now with potency it has at least it would blind. after lv 56 u can just forget u have that skill atall.
Blood Price - this skill is becoming less and less useful. Only use it has now it to get blood stacks in trash bulls to make Quietus manna gain aoes. and fixing it behind grit after that heavy mp regen nef is unnecessary.
PLD:
Total Eclipse - need enmity increase similar to abyssal drain not as strong as on flash or unleash but still increased on so dps aoe won't rip aggro off you.

[Tufelhunden]

i have all 3 tanks on 70:

my dummy 10min parse result atm:
War 3.1k pld 2.9k drk 2.8k:

So with a SAM or ninja. Pld is identical to the warrior, with better utility and Drk is 100 dps behind, presuming my math is correct.