Why are bad hunt behavior rewarded?

[Settiesama]

Interesting clash of ethics. Firstly, you have the consequentialists reviewing the outcome: "Regardless of the rules the outcome is unfavorable. Pulling early causes grief." Secondly, you have the deontologists who review only the rules: "As long as you follow the rules, the outcome is irrelevant. Pulling early is within the rules."

Should we differentiate between what is good and what is right or are they one and the same?

You missed the third group, those of us who don't actually care that it is within the rules, but instead feel insulted by hunting a mob, gathering our group to kill, only to be expected to wait before killing, continuously wait, and then called out with abuse by those who weren't hunting in the first place for early pulling, even if 15-20 minutes has passed.