About Tank Design Winner

[Colino]

I really wanted the Goobue armour to win, oh well.

[Elleia]

I really wanted the Goobue armour to win, oh well.

I think the goobbue armor will (or should) end up being implemented as an outfit that everyone can wear, ala the pig costume from the Gold Saucer. I think it would make more sense to do something like this rather than restrict it to tanking classes only.

[MaeIsMean]

They said it was boring, but seriously, can they come up with something better than the winning entry? Criticism is all fine and dandy if it has substance, but literally just saying "It's boring.", like at least provide some backbone...

Just because someone says it's boring doesn't mean they actually have the artistic talent to create something else. It's perfectly ok to think the winner was boring compared to the other entrants, without actually having to create my own design to "back it up."

[MagiusNecros]

Well, where's your entry?

Where's yours? That's what I thought.

Learn to accept opinions for what they are. Opinions.

[Brady672]

The set that was my favorite won

You know, besides the Goobue set.

[Jynx]

They said it was boring, but seriously, can they come up with something better than the winning entry?

You should really read your own comment back to yourself and then ask yourself.

Does that make any sense?

Go on I'll wait.

[Teraluna]

This armour removes all your skills - because you don't need them. All you do is stand there and say "and that was your Ultimate? Thought you where just tickling me"

[Nuna]

This armour removes all your skills - because you don't need them. All you do is stand there and say "and that was your Ultimate? Thought you where just tickling me"

Looks like Iron Tarkus upgraded his armor.

[Beckett]

And that point to win the DPS and Healer design contest. All you have to do is to remember to take a design that looks like its in the game already (not interesting, fun designs like the others were. Oh no no no), use it as a base and design your artwork off of that.. You'll win

That's probably the worst thing about this pick. If they have more design contests, I get the feeling we're going to see most entries going the safe, easy route and creating gear that looks like stuff we already have in the game. I'm sure we'll still get crazy outliers, but I'm expecting a lot more generic entries for the next contest now that people know that's what gets you the win.

[ErryK]

You should really read your own comment back to yourself and then ask yourself.

Does that make any sense?

Go on I'll wait.

I don't think it's fair for an individual to judge a piece when they aren't in the position to judge it, that's why we had this one judged by the devs and I'm thankful for that. Had this been judged by players, probably some impractical Gobbuue armor or single-thread armor would have won, knowing how impractical this player based is. SE is only looking out for what the fans want. How this 180 on the Allagan Luminous Surcoat happened, baffles me, which is why I am asking... have you created anything better? Has it been judged and won the competition? No? Didn't think so.