Pros and Cons of each Healer Role

[Kelya]

I am curious how those compare with Rouse + Whispering Dawn. I guess the specific with what you are saying is it sounds very targeted on 1 person (the tank) with regen / a.ben

WHM
DS (+30% potency) + Regen + Med2 + Asylum
195+65+100 potency / tick
1365+650+800 total potency

Single target : 360 potency / tick
AOE : 165 potency / tick

Total single target : 2815 potency over 30s....... 3815 over 45s (Regen + Med2 reapplied to compare with the 45s of AST HOTs) ....... 2520 over 21s (stopped at 21s to compare with the 21s of SCH HOT)
Total AOE : 1450 potency over 30s....... 1700 over 45s....... 1155 over 21s


AST
Synastry (+20% potency) + AB + AH + CU + Time Dilation (+15s)
168+48+150 potency / tick
1848+720+1500 total potency

Single target : 366 potency / tick
AOE : 198 potency / tick

Total single target : 4068 potency over 45s....... 3660 over 30s (stopped at 30s to compare with the 30s of WHM HOTs)....... 2562 over 21s
Total AOE : 2220 over 45s.......1980 over 30s....... 1386 over 21s

SCH
Rouse (+40% potency) + Whispering

Single target / AOE : 93,33 potency / tick

Total single target / AOE : 653,33 potency over 21s


I've done that quickly so the maths might be wrong haha

Edit : If you take in account the fairy it should be around the same (a bit less or more) as WHM/AST over 21s for single target

[Kaurie]

snip

It is a little hard for me to follow all your numbers, but one or two things. Eos's potency is less than regular potency (about 66% so 300 Eos potency = 200 player potency). Also, I find Medica II is about 40% of the power of Whispering Dawn when Divine Sealed IIRC, but if I understand your calcs you are saying that Medica II is higher?

I may look into this more when I am home, but I am not largely concerned. I mostly just wanted to point out that Scholars can also bring a significant HoT, which seems to go largely ignored.

[Kelya]

It is a little hard for me to follow all your numbers, but one or two things. Eos's potency is less than regular potency (about 66% so 300 Eos potency = 200 player potency). Also, I find Medica II is about 40% of the power of Whispering Dawn when Divine Sealed IIRC, but if I understand your calcs you are saying that Medica II is higher?

I may look into this more when I am home, but I am not largely concerned. I mostly just wanted to point out that Scholars can also bring a significant HoT, which seems to go largely ignored.

With the 200 potency from Eos then you're looking at 2940 potency over 21s of single target healing so it's a bit more than AST/WHM for this duration.
DS Med2 < Rouse Whispering as it's 455 potency vs 980 over 21s respectively. I don't know what's confusing except the few numbers I've put just to show from where I got my final results ^^