Quote Originally Posted by Syzygian View Post
PLD and DRK are the ones that are on more or less equal footing
I disagree; DRK is significantly more potent than PLD in the current meta.

When one tank is way ahead of the other's its overpowered, it doesn't make the other two tanks underpowered.
Not as a rule, it doesn't. Let's say DRK and PLD did 33% of the DPS that WAR could do, but WAR is only pulling 300 DPS. By your logic, WAR is overpowered, even though they're all incredibly weak. One class being better than another doesn't prove, as a rule, that one or the other is over or underpowered. I understand that people use these terms loosely, but you're using it to justify nerfing WAR.

if PLD seemed poor in comparison to both, that'd be a different story
It is poor in comparison to both.

Frankly its all subjective.
Bullshit; you just can't (or won't) come up with any objective criteria to bolster your proposition.

I would go so far as to flip your argument over and say why SHOULD WAR be SO MUCH more powerful than the other tanks, OVERALL in both MT and OT DPS while being equal in mitigation/equal in utility?
I never said it should be. And, for the record, I don't think it should be. Again, what's in contention is whether or not WAR deserves to be nerfed; it's not the only solution to the problem of tank balance.