Quote Originally Posted by karateorangutang View Post
NEEDED is not the argument. You can probably do anything soon with any composition but thats not the argument. Its not optimal to bring PLD/DRK for anything currently. Any group that doesn't have tanks that are sticks in the mud are gonna bring at least one WAR to a raid. SE/SP > than any other utility that any other tank offers.

If this is your opinion then that is fine. If your stating it as a fact then back it up with some info.
you want to talk optimal? Fine, it's not optimal to bring BRD or Machinist either in DPS checks, are those unbalanced and broken? No? okay.