Quote Originally Posted by Aeyis View Post
Your troll opinion is duly noted. Please read the threads replies previous to your ''could someone please tell me what the plotholes are??? you havent yet???''.
It is there you will find your answer.


Also, on the topic of logical connections:

-You ask what the plotholes are. Second part of that post specifies no plotholes have been mentioned.
- However plotholes (valid and invalid plotholes) have been mentioned before.
- Implies that your question is not an honest one.
- Your current post only replies to a gip, and not to the actual arguments in a post.

logical conclusion: you are a troll.
result: ''Your troll opinion is duly noted''


Logic.
Yes well if you edit back the list of plot holes into a message I replied to ten minutes after the reply, I can't take them into account can I? But since you so nicely replied, I will attempt the same.

The plotholes here is that all of them died when they really shouldnt have. Source? We never really saw any of them die on screen. I wish at least one of them to die, but like I said we never saw anything.
Portculis could have been dropped from the other side. Overdrives could have been used in a none self-destructive way. Well the army got passed the dropped portcullis anyway and caught up to us even with Papalymo and Yda holding the line, so I don't think simply dropping the portcullis would have worked. By overdrive I guess you mean limit breaks. I didn't see Yda suffer any damage due to doing that AOE final heaven that frankly, the player has no acces to.
Who ever heard of someone in the history of gaming using a holy when they werent immune to its effects themselves? Where did you read that Y'shtola used holy? It was never said. Besides it wasn't the spell itself that killed her, if she is dead, but the stones that fell due to the explosion.
Ah yes and one more: Hydaelyn suddenly talking to Minfilia. Hydaelyn tends to warn people beforehand, not afterwards. Well first off we don't know what enabled her to speak again. Maybe she was still gagged by something untill that specific moment. Second, we cannot know what she said to Minfilia. It seems less of a warning than a command based on Minfilia's reaction.
The plotholes here are: you track down one of your favored Crystal Braves, yet easily believe the words of a suspected Brave who just happened to be there. He was on patroll and well you didn't have any particular suspects at that point.
You just happen to get a personal invite from the Sultana. Odd, considering she should have expected you to be at the feast. Actually, she should have been there herself. So you think it is wrong not to suspect that the Sultana is up to no good. I know I said she likely planned her suicide, but you have to be really paranoid to suspect Nanamo of anything evil.
Also your character just sits there passively as she 'dies'. Well storyline deaths cannot be averted by ingame mechanics. If that were so, all Elder Scrolls characters would just eat rocks to stay alive. Aerith says hello.

When the brass blades etc come, it makes no sense to just come with them. Weve had betrayals, we fought the empire and what not. We can see where this is going, and with his timing he was likely responsible for all of it. Sure, but are you willing to just cut down the most well connected person in Eorzea and run out of the bedchamber of the dead Sultana with corpses following your trail?
What, you say we had no weapon? Plothole. Why on earth would I not have my weapon with me. All the other leaders had their weapons at the feast. Well yes, that is true. But we were escorted into the bedchamber of the Sultana. I can totally imagine a need to remove your weapons when you enter. And at the very least, the guards would have disarmed you after placing you into custody. I personally think the guards leaving you armed would have been a plot hole.
Besides, you might recall Yshtola using holy without using her wand. Im sure that as an actual white mage instead of a conjurer (which is Yshtolas class, when did she learn holy exactly?I guess they made her a white mage suddenly, ah another plothole) I could have done the same. Well NPC-s don't always adher to the class system. You know like Merlwyb dual wielding pistols, which is frankly impossible and will remain such even during 3.0 Y'shtola is classified as a conjurer, but she always had abilities that adventurers like us do not have. In 1.0 she deflected bullets with her hands, conjured up shields and created duplicates of herself.

Anything else?