Soldiery Weapons: What's your opinion?

[Sylkis]

The SCH book is terrible. About the weapon damage argument, I would agree if it's tank or DPS, but for healers the extra bit of HP healed is wasted as an overheal sometimes. A crit shield from Aldo can make a huge difference, so the t5 weapon is superior IMO. Even if I'm wrong about that, the other weapons are a better use of the tomestone and soldiery.

Oh and yes, weapon damage will increase adloq shield, but I would rather have a 1% extra chance to save someone than 100% chance to make no difference at all