caps on all side quests and missions

[Alaltus]

Of course not.

Similarly, you don't need a tank or a healer.

But it certainly does make it a lot less frustrating if you have them.

At any rate, my original point remains - just because you like it one way does not mean everyone should be forced to do it that way. My suggested solution, along with matching achievements, allows you to get your sense of accomplishment while allowing others to make progress without frustration.

Maybe im a minority but when it comes to achievements or trying to beat other players time's i couldnt care less. Ultimately there will always be some group who will have found a way to hit the shortest amount of time possible to win said content before you've even begun it. Real incentives/accomplishments are rewards that give you an edge. For example in promies the big reward for that (besides unlocking new areas) were the rings that couldnt easily be matched by any other rings. I think that denying players the rings/best reward at the end if they havent completed the content under cap would be a much more effective incentive, that way the players who just want to fly through can play through the story without being hindered by difficulty. But only those who stepped up to that difficulty get that extra reward.

[Perrin_Aybarra]

Maybe im a minority but when it comes to achievements or trying to beat other players time's i couldnt care less. Ultimately there will always be some group who will have found a way to hit the shortest amount of time possible to win said content before you've even begun it. Real incentives/accomplishments are rewards that give you an edge. For example in promies the big reward for that (besides unlocking new areas) were the rings that couldnt easily be matched by any other rings. I think that denying players the rings/best reward at the end if they havent completed the content under cap would be a much more effective incentive, that way the players who just want to fly through can play through the story without being hindered by difficulty. But only those who stepped up to that difficulty get that extra reward.

I would be willing to compromise that way if people are so bent on getting the easy way out of things. Give them the story but the unique rewards for completion with a cap.

Things like time attack record is kinda crapy, doesn't give any real accomplishment other than saying you outleveled the content so much you facerolled that much faster...

[Cutriss]

I would be willing to compromise that way if people are so bent on getting the easy way out of things. Give them the story but the unique rewards for completion with a cap.

Things like time attack record is kinda crapy, doesn't give any real accomplishment other than saying you outleveled the content so much you facerolled that much faster...

1. In my suggestion, the time trials would be tiered for the "suggested level" and then beyond, so you could compete for best completion time at your capped level, as well as have fun seeing how quickly you can blow it away 20 levels higher.

2. Don't forget that the end of COP was effectively capped for the better part of a few years. You're saying that people who steamrolled Promyvion and Diabolos but did Tenzen/Promathia at the same level as everyone else don't deserve rings?

[Perrin_Aybarra]

1. In my suggestion, the time trials would be tiered for the "suggested level" and then beyond, so you could compete for best completion time at your capped level, as well as have fun seeing how quickly you can blow it away 20 levels higher.

2. Don't forget that the end of COP was effectively capped for the better part of a few years. You're saying that people who steamrolled Promyvion and Diabolos but did Tenzen/Promathia at the same level as everyone else don't deserve rings?

I understand better you time trial now, while they could be ok to have, they in no mean promote to do the fights at the desgined level.

Not sure I get your question, but if you are asking me if the people who facerolled through CoP after they removed the cap so for exemple did the promies at level 90 instead of 30 for the 1st ones and 50 for the vzhal (sp? lol) and diabolos at 90 while it was designed for level 60 if I remember, and finished the last fight of the story at again 90 when it was designed for level 75 (or lower?) Then yes, imo, they do not deserve the ring at the end. Unlocking the story areas and seeing the story is well enough for those people while the ones that did it at capped levels, came up with strategies to beat those fights and persevered and triumphed, they deserve the reward at the end as a proof of hardship. Clearly they deserve it more from where I stand. And please don't think me as an elitist jerk because I am not, I would say the same thing if I was on the other side and went through those missions when there was no challenge involved.

[Cutriss]

Not sure I get your question, but if you are asking me if the people who facerolled through CoP after they removed the cap so for exemple did the promies at level 90 instead of 30 for the 1st ones and 50 for the vzhal (sp? lol) and diabolos at 90 while it was designed for level 60 if I remember, and finished the last fight of the story at again 90 when it was designed for level 75 (or lower?) Then yes, imo, they do not deserve the ring at the end. Unlocking the story areas and seeing the story is well enough for those people while the ones that did it at capped levels, came up with strategies to beat those fights and persevered and triumphed, they deserve the reward at the end as a proof of hardship. Clearly they deserve it more from where I stand. And please don't think me as an elitist jerk because I am not, I would say the same thing if I was on the other side and went through those missions when there was no challenge involved.

I was really speaking more to the people who completed it after the caps were lifted but before leveling to 80.

theres only one real reason to not want caps on missions, it's straight up lazyness.

I'm pretty sure I already delineated a reason to not want them. Laziness on your part was deciding not to read my posts.

[Perrin_Aybarra]

I was really speaking more to the people who completed it after the caps were lifted but before leveling to 80.

Well... I am not playing FFXI anymore so really in my heart I would say no they don't deserve the same thing others got by skill and perseverance BUT my head says sure they can have it since anyways that gear is probably out-dated with the level raised to 99. So they can have it even tho they should feel no accomplishment on getting to the end of it.

Edit: err I didn't see your "before leveling to 80".. if they did all the missions on the appropriate level, sure they shoud feel good about themselves, if they did ALL the missions on level 75-80 (like even the promies lvl 30, the mammets, diabolos, etc) then it's still the same.. no real accomplishment for them.