Warrior "buff" in 2.1: not what we are expecting?

[Bfmusashi]

Both tanks receive a hit of 1000 damage.

PLD takes 800 requires 800 healing.

WAR takes 1000 requires 1000 healing.

800 x 1.25 (25%) = 1000, therefore the warrior requires 25% more healing than the PLD does.

Your math sucks.

in your example the Paladin requires a spell that hits for 800hp recovery. The Warrior needs a spell that would normally hit for about 833 (1.20*833=999.6). While your point stands your math did not.

[Exhaltia]

in your example the Paladin requires a spell that hits for 800hp recovery. The Warrior needs a spell that would normally hit for about 833 (1.20*833=999.6). While your point stands your math did not.

That's not accurate. His math was right. The point was to highlight why -20% damage does not equal +20% healing and was assuming the heal would be coming from the same caster, healing for the same amount, not a different amount or different caster. He was pointing out a perceived flaw with the changes, not how the heals would have to be different using the changes.

[Phreak]

in your example the Paladin requires a spell that hits for 800hp recovery. The Warrior needs a spell that would normally hit for about 833 (1.20*833=999.6). While your point stands your math did not.

My math is perfectly fine, I was not including the warrior healing received bonus at all. I was showing that there was a 25% base healing tax that WARs have to make up to be on par with PLDs as far as healing efficiency goes. Showing that in order for the stances to be EQUAL, the point that was challenged in the original post I responded to, the bonus on defiance would have to be 25% NOT 20%.

In order for WAR to recover at the same cost as the PLD the bonus would need to be 25%, what is so hard for you people to understand about this? It was talked about months ago.

@ Phreak

I honestly don't even know what the hell you're saying anymore. It doesn't take some long drawn out bullshit scenario to show that to equal a 20% damage reduction in terms of healing efficiency/healing required to recover, a bonus of 25% healing received is needed. I am not talking about eHP at all, nor did I ever mention it you seem to be mixing them all together for some reason.