Thinking of switching to PLD...

[Sephirah]

Both Defiance and Shield Oath IMO should give 20% less damage, you're never going to balance a stance that gives flat mitigation vs a small HP buff, Keep Warriors as the the heal tank for flavor, but without 20% less damage theyll never be good as PLD even for AOE tanking which PLD does better still with flash spam and circle of scorn, Overpower runs you out of TP in seconds and only hits in a tiny cone

If I could unlike your post I would.

WAR is fine the way it is, if they also received a 20% less damage buff from Defiance there would be absolutely zero reason for anyone to be a pld. You get more dmg, health, and healing. You don't get to have the increased defense too.

Warriors, stop expecting to be essentially the exact same as pld just with an axe. Your skills are designed to be played differently. If you want to have pld abilities, roll a pld.