Having your character talk during cutscenes

[Shougun]

I disagree entirely. Sorry. In the end, I think this is a terrible idea, and has been proven as a terrible idea by a couple of recent MMOs that have tried doing this. Every time you end up with this character who isn't you saying things you wouldn't say. It's a horrid idea and I hope it never happens.

I dont think because a company does it poorly that the idea itself is poor. In that matter anything FFXIV 1.0 did was a horrid idea and Yoshida made a horrible decision by keeping anything it had. (which some argue lol) But I know most people felt comfortable keeping most aspects but just reworking it a lot.

Imo, not a horrible idea and I think you are being highly unfair by pointing out mmos that failed entirely as example why the idea is bad.