Quote Originally Posted by bobbygunz View Post
The guy who wasn't rolling for seals originally obviously joined the party purely to help his friend. If he won the roll on the seal, it's his to do as he pleases, whether that be to give it to a friend or not.

It is sometimes hard to find people to join a party, so having him in the party to begin with meant that everyone had a chance to get a seal. He won the seal fairly, and he did what he wanted to with it. End of story.
This...

You lost the roll, doesn't matter what the guy did with it who won the roll because you had your chance at it.

He could destroy it at that point if he wanted too.