Thief, Musketeer, Dark Knight, and Arcanist

[Gumbercules]

haven't read all the posts so sorry if im just repeating, but if drk was still a tanking class the idea of it replacing pld as the players choice doesn't sound that bad. Im thinking let there be a repeatable quest to let the player return to the light or fall into darkness etc. It would be fun to have drk be a "health" siphon style tank and have pld be a "self heal or party heal" tank type, even have like a health sacrifice style spell for the drk that he can heal himself from taking allies health.
...just my two cents. >.>

Forgot Warrior :P but still believe there's a way to make things of this sort work out in a fashion that adds to the game-play even if it feels like a restriction.