Quote Originally Posted by Zyph View Post
The receiving end of the spell in all of these games is not another spell, it's a creature aligned to or comprised of the weak element. In Water -> Lightning's case, a creature that produces/is comprised of electricity would be shorted out by water.

You wanna talk ridiculous, Ice and Water are the same thing, one is just colder. I'm assuming the "Ice" element is just a manifestation of cold, though.
Thus is the point, they are all ridiculous so what point is there in arguing over them. There is no logical elemental wheel, because an elemental wheel itself is entirely illogical