"I want people to be forced into the content I want them to be forced into. Because surely, someone not wanting to be there is going to put 100% effort in and not completely phone it in and make this take way longer than it should."

It's like people don't understand that when someone feels forced to do something, they are going to put in the bare minimum effort, and probably just 1-1-1-1-1-1-1 and die a lot.
It would be overall more efficient to have someone who wants to be there rather than have a warm body just taking up a spot.

But this is typical western thinking at it's most typical.
"You should do what I want you to do. But you should also still do it to the best of your ability because I said so."

As if this somehow isn't the most narcissistic way of thinking imaginable.