I would just like to note that Mog is probably the fore most expert on this game then anyone posting right now, and although I do not agree with all of his opinions, the facts he states are facts and trying to win a debate by proclaiming your opinon > facts is ignorant. Personally, I have very little issues controlling hate with a total of +8 enmity on my entire gear, and with no HP materia what so ever I am only 200hp short that of my war in the same exact gear, and when parsed on multiple boss fights, my PLD takes roughly 10-5k less damage on avg then my war, making that 200 hp dismoly unconsequntial to the debate. I perfer my PLD tank over my WAR because I can infact replace a Healer allowing for a much better DD into the fight then WAR can do to keep up with. Simply put , both classes are fine, IF there was anything I would suggest to the devs to help PLD is to make Holy Succor instant cast, consume as much tp and second wind and put it on a 30-45 second cool down. This frees up mp for cures and stone skin.