The problem with Tripling Down on Shadowbringers Job Design

[Valence]

The PvP kits themselves are directly inspired by the PvE kits. So, logically, if you were to take the PvP kits and take inspiration from them to make a PvE kit, logically speaking, you would end up with something that looks similar to the current PvE kits.

The claim then, that the PvP kits have things that the PvE kits could take inspiration from should then be tested. This is why, you start at the PvP kit, take the things out that only apply to PvP, replace with some PvE centred things and make a new kit. Now, if what you come up with is something similar to the PvE kit, then the PvP kit really isn't that inspiring is it?

So aagin, the question is, what is so inspiring about the PvP kits that the PvE kits could learn from?

But what is "being inspired by" exactly? How do you define this inspiration between pvp and pve kits? We both can play at this little game.

That's pure sophistry you've been doing since the beginning and you know it. You know what people mean, your strategy is just to derail everything into meaningless minutiae that completely misses the bigger picture.

As for the last paragraph, this is the problem with people at the moment. They have blurred the lines so much that everything looks the same. However, the miss the nuance associated with each individual thing that makes them unique. This is what I am trying to make people see. These things are not the same and they all have different considerations applied to each one. There is only so much you can do to make things feel distinct when everyone is looking at things from such a broad perspective. get in there, take in the nuance.

We could tell you that two inner release type bursts feel the same, you'd still come up and tell us "akshtually, the GCD used in both don't have the same potency so they're technically very different!"

You're being constantly disingenuous and missing the point on purpose.