[Feedback] Wuk Lamat's English Voice

[LilithRose]

Complaining about the voice. Check

Oh, is it not usual for people to stay on topic?

Dismissing the blatant transphobia. Check

Should I detail how many people talked how racist her accent was too? We're talking about voice acting here. Who this person is in real life is none of my concern. I am not here to make personal attacks.

Dismissing criticism of other voice performances. Check

I've noted a lackluster voice acting there too. And noted how people making this argument are arguing completely in bad faith. /Check

Implying Sena isn't a professional actress. Check

More bad faith by assigning implications to another person. /Check

(also this is one of the most telling things because if this was really a problem you had, you'd be laying the blame at the casting director)

I don't really like playing the blame game. But... I actually did.

However I do not think a main character in a big beloved main entry to the Final Fantasy series is necessarily a place for practice. XIV has come a long way from it's humble roots where they had to re-make so much of the game, to now start dipping into a cheap hiree for a main character.

And in all my personal discussions, I said just the same. An actor like this, under any other circumstances would've been a "NEXT!" from the casting director. This was before I learned a bit more about the actor. And my opinion hasn't changed.

Also noticing that "it's just legitimate criticism" is the new "it's about ethics in games journalism" has been a revelation.

Indeed, it is quite sad to see SJW warriors and Activists try and inhabit this topic as well. Clearly they are not mature enough to understand when a person gives criticism, it can truly be just that. Criticism. And I do not consider a person's gender to be part of politics.




Now if you really want to show your sincerity about contributing to the topic, why don't you tell me how you really felt about my post?

*Edit

See now you just telling on yourself.

You just keep telling Yourself that. It shows your post is nothing more than a bad attempt at provocation rather than contributing.

[DrForester]

quite sad to see SJW warriors and Activists

See now you just telling on yourself.

[Mosha]

Update: still haven't done 6.55, went fishing.

[ZiraZ]

NONONONONO! SHUT IT DOWN!
BUMPING IS NOT ALLOWED!
MODS!
EXECUTE THESE CANNIBALISTIC HUMANOID UNDERGROUND DWELLERS!!!

[CVXIV]

I was wondering if the thread would ever get bumped honestly.
We'll just have to wait and see how the performance is in Dawntrail.

[sindriiisgaming]

i WISH that i was satisfied enough with the game that THIS was my major complaint

[LilithRose]

Update: still haven't done 6.55, went fishing.

Good choice, I've been enjoying myself a good amount of fishing too. First level 90 this expansion ♥

NONONONONO! SHUT IT DOWN!
BUMPING IS NOT ALLOWED!
MODS!
EXECUTE THESE CANNIBALISTIC HUMANOID UNDERGROUND DWELLERS!!!

It's not bumping if you actually post something worthwhile to say.

I was wondering if the thread would ever get bumped honestly. Which you clearly don't... you're only contributing to what you seem to hate. A discussion about criticism... oh the horror.
We'll just have to wait and see how the performance is in Dawntrail.

Absolutely. Things can change. But both the German and JP voices sound wonderful that I won't need to hold my breath for it.

i WISH that i was satisfied enough with the game that THIS was my major complaint

I've been playing it moderately for over a decade now.. I haven't felt FOMO for this game as much as others, and taken frequent breaks. So whilst this expansion certainly was a bit more lackluster than others before. I portion myself enough not to get burned out and keep myself satisfied with the story. So not too many complaints,

Outside of that they should fix my damn healers!

And the voice, it's nothing world shattering. But it left enough of a confused impression for me to try and figure out what the heck was going on.

[Valkyrie_Lenneth]

The thing is, if the rest of the voice acting in a patch was off, and we have historical data to show how those voice actors sound (IE, every other patch they speak in), then I would make the assumption that something else happened with the English voice overs in this path, and any irregularities aren't the fault of the voice actors. Unfortunately this is Sena's first appearance, so people are hyperfocusing on that, instead of the lackluster performance overall by all. AKA, this isn't the fault of the voice actors and is on the production team.


Krile and G'raha sounded horrible to me, it jumped out like a sore thumb compared to past recordings.

[CVXIV]

Good choice, I've been enjoying myself a good amount of fishing too. First level 90 this expansion ♥
It's not bumping if you actually post something worthwhile to say.
Absolutely. Things can change. But both the German and JP voices sound wonderful that I won't need to hold my breath for it.
I've been playing it moderately for over a decade now.. I haven't felt FOMO for this game as much as others, and taken frequent breaks. So whilst this expansion certainly was a bit more lackluster than others before. I portion myself enough not to get burned out and keep myself satisfied with the story. So not too many complaints,

Outside of that they should fix my damn healers!

And the voice, it's nothing world shattering. But it left enough of a confused impression for me to try and figure out what the heck was going on.

I don't know why you replied to me and put words in my mouth when I've been in this thread and the other one since the beginning and I agreed that the voice acting sounded weird to me.

Edit: https://forum.square-enix.com/ffxiv/...90#post6407590
One of my previous posts.

[HeyMcFly]

How would those who don't like this NPC's english voice rather sound?