Quote Originally Posted by Renathras View Post
As noted above: I remember a week or so ago when I suggested adding Holy to the single-target rotation and you insisted against it, pointing out Holy is an AOE ability and is for AOE, and how you dislike that Misery, an AOE ability, is used in single-target rotations.

...Aero 3 is AOE. To show consistency with your stated viewpoint, shouldn't you be arguing against it's addition OR insisting it be a DPS loss over Glare so that it won't be used in single-target, considering you dislike Misery being part of the single-target rotation and oppose Holy being part of it? I'm not asking this as a gotcha, more just noting an inconsistency.

I also find it odd how anyone would see Aero 3 and go "man, that's some depth right there!"
Thank you for once again putting words in my mouth.

At what point did I ever say that it was a DPS loss? Last I checked I agreed that for your idea to work Holy had to have a boost as you made it so it WOULDN'T be a loss?

Also I did say that I had preferred Misery to take Holy's place in your rotation specifically because it was more of a single target button than Holy ever was unless you also want to change Holy to be 50% less damage to anything other than the target (assuming you are still making Holy be ranged)?

Aero 3 does not have to come back as an AOE. It can literally be another DoT on a shorter CD and I would be fine with it. If it comes back as an AOE I don't think I'd like it other than it gives WHM another AOE attack (which I would argue all healers should get anyway) but its whatever. As was your rotation.

Would I rather have Aero 3 or your rotation? Probably Aero 3 because at least I have another DoT to juggle regardless of whether or not it is AOE. Would I rather have your idea of Dia proccing say a Misery or Assize/other DPS button over Aero 3? Also sure. And I said as much.

"Glare > Glare > Glare > buffed Holy" may fit the criteria of a simple rotation, but it isn't a welcomed one to me.

I see no reason for 3 single target presses to then ask for an AOE one just because you don't want to add in another button for a class that doesn't struggle with button bloat in comparison to its peers.

It doesn't feel right. It doesn't feel fun to play. You don't like that answer? Tough. Its the same answer I gave to Ty when he suggested cards on the GCD. Don't know why you want to fixate on that.