I've played around with it and I kinda like it?
On paper I wasn't really very excited about the fact that Goring Blade is reliant on crits like every high potency move in the game, but the feel of job is pretty okay honestly.
I think the fact that you can fuck up and use req on holy spirits and all that jank makes it feel like you're playing the job, rather than the job playing itself.

It feels like a WoW class weirdly enough. Pretty sure it has a priority system now rather than a strict spreadsheet style rotation but I wouldn't know.
I am however, not a PLD main. The last time I played PLD on a "high-ish" level was O9S and O10S, so honestly, old PLD mains should be the ones that we need to hear from.