Give us back the old Paladin

[Mikey_R]

So that it can still be proc'd by another player should the boss jump and be untargetable/not wasting any MP on a clemency especially given the newer rotation being more MP heavy.

Except the new rotation is NOT MP heavy. You do NOT need to do the 2 minute rotation with hard casting Holy Spirits and that is the only case where MP is an issue. It has been proven, both mathematically and practically that just doing the rotation, however you want, whether that is hardcasting Holy Spirit, doing the 1 minute loop with 2 divine Holy Spirits or just using everything as it comes makes virtually NO difference to damage.

[Alpheus]

Except the new rotation is NOT MP heavy. You do NOT need to do the 2 minute rotation with hard casting Holy Spirits and that is the only case where MP is an issue. It has been proven, both mathematically and practically that just doing the rotation, however you want, whether that is hardcasting Holy Spirit, doing the 1 minute loop with 2 divine Holy Spirits or just using everything as it comes makes virtually NO difference to damage.

I can only speak to my limited experience with the new design given my limited playtime but you do make a fair point. The basis of the idea was to not have to allow for a clemency cast as your only recourse should the boss be un-targetable because I know PLD in general tries to avoid that when at all possible while still keeping old DV's interplay mechanic.

I'm perfectly fine with how it is currently as old Shake it Off personally speaking. The animation is neat and it fits just fine. Was just offering a suggestion that could allow for some that old vibe back that that one poster was missing.