Quote Originally Posted by EaraGrace View Post
Posting these again.
“Our journey” doesn’t exactly scream “we’re different groups of people.”
No matter how many times you post it, cherry-picking one sentence where she uses the word that encompases both "you" and "me" together when talking about something that refers to all of us won't make the other instances where she treated us as "her childs", like she's our mother who gave us birth, go away. I don't think she spoke to the other ancients in the same way when she was still Venat. Do you ever see her address Emet or Hythlodaeus as "my child"?


Quote Originally Posted by EaraGrace View Post
And in Elpis she repeatedly uses “we” when discussing our plans for what to do next, referring to her and us.
I see a pattern. You're putting too much weight on words like "we" and "our" which are SUPER common in regular coversation to refer to multiple subjects including the speaker. Is that all you got to make your point? Do you make such a distinction when speaking about "we and our dog"? Is that natural to you?

Also, in those last 2 screenshots she's still talking as Venat, the sundering is far away from happening yet, why would she talk in a funny way to make a forceful distinction at that point?


Quote Originally Posted by EaraGrace View Post
Venat and Hydaelyn consistently make clear we are united and while different in nature, both are of mankind.
Addressed in my previous points, but regardless, she has said many things, some which have been backpedaled explicitly in the story (like the convo with the Watcher) but actions speak louder than words. She didn't believe in humanity so she took it upon herself (without prior consultation) to sunder and create a new one that she believed would fare better. So much for unity. Also, that "humanity" that was in the other shards was gonna get abandoned in her escape plan. Guess they weren't humanity enough, as she was only concerned with the ones on the Source.