Current top 100th percentile on P1S since 6.08 buffs

[CKNovel]

Various words

What's up these days with these wrong takes...

1. Yes there will always be a bottom but MCH is not a suitable job for the bottom.
It only brings DPS, it should at the minimum have a correct DPS.
DNC brings healing and shielding, yet it's above MCH. Imagine if BLM was below SMN and RDM.

In the melee case, if we use your logic, then NIN and DRG would be the top, RPR and MNK would be bottom in the Melee group.

2. No, MNK is in the average APM.
It's below SAM, DRG and GNB due to its very low number of oGCD.
Also dude... Everyone needs to look out for mechanics. It's not a MNK problem, especially when your mobility tool is a non damaging oGCD and you have little oGCDs.

Ninja and MCH are much higher APM than MNK.

3. On a complexity scale of 0 to 100, SMN is a 1, BLM is a 15, 20 at most.
You gotta stop thinking it's a complex job when each expansions just gives more and more mobility. You can become a ranged for 10 GCDs.

4. Again, it's not a "Monk exclusive problem", it's every job.
Every job needs to play well to deal damage. Every melee needs to stay close to the boss.
MNK is not complex, uptime is not difficult especially in this tier. Remember most group seeks the most uptime strats and

Sorry but you're the one narrow-minded.
Free mobility, "GCD job", average APM.
MNK is among the easiest job

Oh yeah about your consistency argument, get ready to implode:
In 6.05, DRK could AFK a whole minute to respect mechanics and still outdps PLD.
Currently, I wouldn't doubt BLM could AFK and still outdps SMN/RDM.
This is why we need balance.

It's not the MCH fault if you die or fail to maintain your uptime
But in UCOB, UWU, TEA, O11S it was their responsibility to deal with mechanics so you could have your uptime.