Another MSQ roulette post: We need change on some level

[Kirika-]

So, I was just subjected to the half the party leaves Castrum event and I got to say it's dumb and it should be an actionable offense besides the penalty. You willingly queued into a roulette and left when it wasn't the one you wanted. You know the risks involved when queuing into it. You are affecting other peoples experiences when you do this and then they have to requeue into it and have to wait however long it takes.

I understand things can happen and you have to leave, sometimes at the very beginning of a duty, but for those that intentionally do it, yeah you know who are, should be some form of actionable punishment.

Luckily my group just pugged it: Me as Reaper(Tank), Dancer, Ninja and Astro. It took us 32 mins to do it from start to finish with cutscenes included so no excuse as to why

So there needs to be change on some level for it whether it be an actual offense or some thing much more milder than that. I'm just looking out for other rather than myself.

Thank you for listening to my TED talk whomever you are!

It is an actionable offense.

TIP...If you are queued for MSQ Roulette and get Castrum:

1. Once the instance starts (the pen around the group disappears), swing your character's camera view around to see the party face on and take a screen shot. Wait till after the pen disappears, otherwise those who are still in cut scene will have their names as "Viewing Cutscene" in your party list.
2. If players drop right after the searchlights are switched off (just after the first cut scene) and/or before the first "boss fight", take another screen shot.
3. After the completion of the dungeon, tab out of the game and open the two screen shots.
4. From the screen shots, you now have the names, jobs, appearance/race, and time frame of who dropped, you can also look up the names on the FF14 website Community/Character Search page to narrow down to the exact player via their World Server (just sort by your Data Center) in-case the same name is used for different characters. You can match the character's appearance/race vs your screen shots to be sure you report the correct individual. You don't need to keep or submit those screen shots, you are just using them as a "notepad" of sorts to have all the party names and times shown.
5. Copy the character name from the search page to paste into your report.
6. Open your in-game menu and go Support Desk/Contact/ and report Harassment.
7. Fill out with the information; Date/Time, violation description "Griefing party via dropping from active instance", paste in the character name(s) and their World Server, and submit.

The whole process should take only a few minutes tops.

Those who dropped will be punished.

[NegativeS]

snip snop

That... sounds like a lot of work for something like that when the system could just be better.

[Kirika-]

That... sounds like a lot of work for something like that when the system could just be better.

Yes, the system could be better, until then you use the methods available.
Not doing anything to help stop it, only allows it to happen more.
Like I said, the whole process would take a few minutes tops.

[Rhysati]

It is an actionable offense.

No it isn't. There are buttons to leave group. You can leave for any reason you want.

[Kirika-]

No it isn't. There are buttons to leave group. You can leave for any reason you want.

It is.
And, yes, it is enforced and those found in violation are punished.
Section: Obstruction of play - Intentional leaving or disconnection

As to if the player's who dropped have a "legit" reason other than "I didn't want the lesser exp run, so I dropped", that is up to the GM's to investigate.

[Valkyrie_Lenneth]

It is.
And, yes, it is enforced and those found in violation are punished.
Section: Obstruction of play - Intentional leaving or disconnection

As to if the player's who dropped have a "legit" reason other than "I didn't want the lesser exp run, so I dropped", that is up to the GM's to investigate.

That is for intentionally disconnecting to force the party to vote dismiss you so you dont take the penalty. Not for leaving an instance which already has a penalty. Otherwise they would just make the leaving penalty increase each instance...

Also, if you start reporting people for leaving you could be actioned for making malicious and false reports lol.

[Kirika-]

That is for intentionally disconnecting to force the party to vote dismiss you so you dont take the penalty. Not for leaving an instance which already has a penalty. Otherwise they would just make the leaving penalty increase each instance...

Also, if you start reporting people for leaving you could be actioned for making malicious and false reports lol.

My link was borked, I fixed it.

Relevant from link:
"However, if a report is filed, a penalty will be issued if the following types of situations are confirmed to be occurring repeatedly:

Occurs right after entering a duty
Occurs when progress is not going well in a duty
Occurs when the team is about to be defeated in PvP

Even if there was no intention to interfere with others, repeated occurrences can be a nuisance to others. If you are experiencing network instability, or if you are frequently unable to play due to real-world circumstances, be considerate of others by refraining from participating in the duty/content, taking into account that you may unintentionally cause issues for others."

[Valkyrie_Lenneth]

My link was borked, I fixed it.

Relevant from link:
"However, if a report is filed, a penalty will be issued if the following types of situations are confirmed to be occurring repeatedly:

Occurs right after entering a duty
Occurs when progress is not going well in a duty
Occurs when the team is about to be defeated in PvP

Even if there was no intention to interfere with others, repeated occurrences can be a nuisance to others. If you are experiencing network instability, or if you are frequently unable to play due to real-world circumstances, be considerate of others by refraining from participating in the duty/content, taking into account that you may unintentionally cause issues for others."

Yes, that is in regards to intentionally disconnecting... they are not talking about using the "Leave duty" button....

Though, if you want to get suspended for malicious reporting, by all means, go for it. No ones stopping you.

If they didn't want anyone leaving instances, they would remove the button.

[Kirika-]

Yes, that is in regards to intentionally disconnecting... they are not talking about using the "Leave duty" button....

Though, if you want to get suspended for malicious reporting, by all means, go for it. No ones stopping you.

If they didn't want anyone leaving instances, they would remove the button.

I'm a regular in MSQ Roulette, get Castrum a lot, I see players drop at start a lot, haven't had any of my reports bite me, they have all been responses of "Thanks for your report, based on the details provided we were able to assess penalties to those involved..."

[Bearded]

I joined a duty two days ago and I had a full system crash as soon as the duty commenced. It took me several minutes to get back in and by the time I did the duty had ended - it was the guildheiest everyone hates (the poison one). I felt so guilty that people might have assumed I disconnected on purpose.