Quote Originally Posted by Chocobits View Post
So the common complaints I see are that:

1. Carby does nothing (literally)
2. We lack an instacast Ruin of any kind anymore
3. Ifrit lowers DPS because of needing to Swiftcast
4. Needs a another/better OGCD

If all of that were addressed, would new SMN not suck in the eyes of the discontented?
None of those meaningfully impact gameplay other than point 4. So no, if those are addressed, I still wouldn't be happy with new SMN, because to me those aren't the core issues with the job.