Quote Originally Posted by Deliciou5 View Post
I removed that part of my second post very early this morning because i didn't think the reward structure for end game gear that square enix would make would have anything to do with whether my idea was good or not.

How did you quote something that wasn't there? Did you have the forum post open all day?
It was simply a pinned tab, mate. They don't auto-refresh. That or you didn't change out that part as early as you thought you did.

I am confused why are you making the same talking points about my idea as the other trolls in this thread did? Alt account?
I'm not. I'm one of the people who responded to said "troll" in defense of your post.

Pretending my end game content shouldn't effect other piece of end game is very bad talking point, since square enix has successfully done this many times in the past with other forms of alternative content every expansion.
There's no pretense, it's not a bad talking point, and XIV has never allowed alternate content to compete with raid gear at the time of that raid gear's release.

Moreover i don't determine the reward structure Square enix does, it makes little difference to my idea to talk about end game gear balance since i trust square to do a good job and it wouldn't be based on any of your excessively verbose hypothetical nonsense.
I never said you determine the reward structure. You don't "determine" squat. But concept which match themselves to the existing (trends in) reward structure are more viable than those that are not, and if you're not aiming at all for viability... why place your idea on a public forum. The devs aren't going to look at it until it's (done some equivalent of having) been retweeted ad nauseum, so the only value you're going to get from this place is constructive feedback.

Ideas on this forum aren't meant to be 1 to 1 implementatation if they ever did use it..its simply there to inspire them to make meaningful content that people would enjoy.
You were given constructive feedback as to what seemed really good about your idea and what you could do to improve it further. If you're only response to informed feedback is that 'it doesn't have to be implemented exactly as I've stated anyways'... why put it on a forum? If you've zero desire to revise or flesh out your concept (a rather good one at its core, I think)... why is it here?