Quote Originally Posted by Vyrerus View Post
It doesn't matter that not every player will use Fantasia. Every player can use Fantasia
You're conflating what is possible with what is actual. It's possible for you to murder, but that doesn't make you a murderer. You'd only be a murderer once you've actualized that possibility.
and it will in no way change Haurchefant's flirtations. This means that player sex is irrelevant, and that Haurchefant is Bi.
Each player character's story is self-contained and isolated. If they weren't, then we'd have to say that poor Haurchefant has gone through the same dialogue and scenes millions of times, including his death. Since this is not the case, then the epistemic warrant to justify the claim that Haurchefant is heterosexual, homosexual, or bisexual is only valid within each particular player character's story. The player character who uses Fantasia will receive epistemic warrant that justifies the claim that Haurchefant is bisexual. The player character who is female will receive epistemic warrant that justifies the claim that Haurchefant is heterosexual. And the player character who is male will receive epistemic warrant that justifies the claim that Haurchefant is homosexual. But all of these scenarios are self-contained and do not bleed into each other. From the perspective of the player character who is female, the events of your player character who may be male do not exist.
Your argument is extremely obtuse, and you know it.
Actually, I believe my argument to be quite good and I don't believe you've been successful in refuting it. And you know it.

Check mate!