It would be much easier to sell a PvP dedicated server to the development team if the current PvP area's were thriving and busy, instead they are deserted and tumbleweeds are rolling about. Asking for a new server requires infrastructure expenditure, and converting an old one requires kicking off all the players who don't want PvP, forcing them out of housing, FC, away from friends all of that stuff. People are arguing like all Yoshi P has to do is click his fingers and a PvP server appears out of thin air. It doesn't work that way.