Open World PvP

[KizuyaKatogami]

For the same reason the rogues guild isn't the thieves guild: the devs have said they want the WoL to be unambiguously good, even if that means RIP your OC or RP.

Right, meanwhile drk questline has us kill and slaughter and bathe in the blood of multiple people and monsters, and now we have Reaper coming out which is even less good. It’s a poor argument.

[ItMe]

And what if i kill People because i declare them as Evil?

Sounds like a holy crusade to me lol.
But SQSX can't control what you the player headcannons, only what your WoL does in narrative.

Right, meanwhile drk questline has us kill and slaughter and bathe in the blood of multiple people and monsters, and now we have Reaper coming out which is even less good. It’s a poor argument.

Right, DRK, the job quest focused around self love and moogles teaching you the meaning of friendship.
Yes how very evil.

And no one knows what Reapers deal will be yet so let's get back to that once we have anything concrete to go off of.