Crafting and Gathering for Everyone: Complete CHANGE to Make it More FUN?

[Roaran]

THIS IS WHAT FISHING SHOULD BE LIKE

Sorry if they could make fishing this awesome in a single player game... how many years ago? It can make it into FFXIV.

[Yves]

I applaud the ideas but I think (personally) that creating a more intricate system is a bad idea. I am in favor of simple, fast, fun, and rewarding. Maybe a really short puzzle game or something (crappy idea.) In terms of rewarding how about more than just the same old crap going around (i.e. - cobalt set, etc..) I mean, hooray...rank 50...now I can make...umm...<sigh> more cobalt body armor...

I have seen the mention of requiring crafters to make the rarer, more epic items and maybe this should be the case. Also, fast is a big deal - taking 90 seconds to craft the same crap for garbage exp gets, well, old.

[waldo]

It's final fantasy. Crafting should be a major pain in the arse to me, the rewards should be great. I think it's sad that people can get all crafts to max level, crafting in FF has never been 'fun' to speak of, I'm not sure you can make it fun tbh. If you had mini-games it'd be cool for about 2 synths, then omg how crappy would it be. Think about what you are saying, a 'parley' (forgive the spelling) type game for each synth... I want to stop crafting now just thinking about it.

The main thing I would change moving foward, make level 50 the cap for all except one skill. Right now you can level everyting to max level, it dilutes the economy, and we all craft to make money. When 1.xx or 2.0 comes out and the level cap raises to 60, or maybe 70, let's keep all but one skill topped at 50. That way if you need your new level 70 bow socketed, or that new level 70 body piece socketed, the person that put the time into working wood or arm to 70 could get paid for that time-sink.

We (most people, i'd argue 90%+) craft, and gather, to make money! It's such a repetitive thing, both crafting and gathering, you can't make it fun. If there were a mini-game for crafting and gathering it'd get really freaking old, really really fast. They have made tons of changes to the system to make it more streamline, faster. A mini-game would destroy all changes that have been made for the better.

[darkstarpoet1]

It's final fantasy. Crafting should be a major pain in the arse to me, the rewards should be great. I think it's sad that people can get all crafts to max level, crafting in FF has never been 'fun' to speak of, I'm not sure you can make it fun tbh. If you had mini-games it'd be cool for about 2 synths, then omg how crappy would it be. Think about what you are saying, a 'parley' (forgive the spelling) type game for each synth... I want to stop crafting now just thinking about it.

The main thing I would change moving foward, make level 50 the cap for all except one skill. Right now you can level everyting to max level, it dilutes the economy, and we all craft to make money. When 1.xx or 2.0 comes out and the level cap raises to 60, or maybe 70, let's keep all but one skill topped at 50. That way if you need your new level 70 bow socketed, or that new level 70 body piece socketed, the person that put the time into working wood or arm to 70 could get paid for that time-sink.

We (most people, i'd argue 90%+) craft, and gather, to make money! It's such a repetitive thing, both crafting and gathering, you can't make it fun. If there were a mini-game for crafting and gathering it'd get really freaking old, really really fast. They have made tons of changes to the system to make it more streamline, faster. A mini-game would destroy all changes that have been made for the better.

to do this they should also make it to where only one battle class and one gathering class can go beyond rank 50. some people craft because they enjoy it. i'm not a fan of limiting what can be leveled beyond 50 at all. think of it this way if it was that way from the start more people would have left months ago because they were out of things to do.

there's no difference in the time and effort that person put in that only does woodworking to 70 than it is for someone that took that same time and effort to get 4 classes to 70. that single rank 70 class took the same amount of time. sure you may have done it 3 times for other classes later, but still took the same amount of time for each one..

[JustMy2Cents]

After reading this thread, it almost sounds like we should get away with leveling as far as crafting goes. For example a mini game (e.g., cooking mama sort...) which increases difficulty depending on the crafting item. Wouldn't this get rid of the grinding aspect and provide some level of challenge to all users?

[Coglin]

While for gathering, I'm always part of the minority that likes the way it is.

I don't think your the minority. Honestly, I think most people lke the gathering itself. I know I do.

[Avraym]

Good suggestions. Would love to see a "cooking mumma" implementation.

Crafting doesn't have to be dull and repititive, we're just gotten used to it.

[Bulwarkz]

i have to say my thoughts are more along the lines with Onizuka than the original op.

Agreed - although I see what the OP is getting at as well. Both would work imo.. crafting is just crafting.

[Avraym]

Agreed - although I see what the OP is getting at as well. Both would work imo.. crafting is just crafting.

Dissagree. "Cooking Mama" sold over 1.6 million copies in its addictive gameplay and appeal. Mario Party DS sold over 5.85 million and the series is still going on strong with its 11th release TBA of the series. The same styles of gaming could be implemented in FFXIV.

This outdated view that crafting has to be dull and tedious because its crafting is outdated.

[Vaen]

Hmm, I don't necessarily agree with some of the OPs idea that sound like they could potentially make crafting more tedious and complicated.

The "restoration" idea for gathering is really cool and could work well though - its always great when you give players more abilities to help each other out/interact with the world positively in an online game.

Honestly, I think crafting AND gathering would be a lot more interesting if they were more visual. As in, instead of these bars and graphs for gathering, you'd actually zoom in on a new texture for a tree/rock/school of fish and choose different-looking spots to pinpoint and gather at. And for crafting, instead of the different-colored balls of light we could actually see the item we're working on and the changing condition it's in throughout the crafting process, at least when crafting finished gear.

I think that would make it more fun without making it more tedious!