That whole thing aside. My point was if they're taking Wind Water and Earth of WHM, for Geomancer it makes more sense given its lore and history to be the DPS role and the new healer to be something else. Sure Geo could be a new healer, so could Chemist, Time Mage, Green Mage, or Shaman. With Geo it just seems to make the least sense given everything we know about the job from within the game and previous iterations.