Feeling punished for having alts...

[Melichoir]

Hon, this question has been answered ad nauseam by more than one person in this very thread. Myself included. Seriously. It's starting to feel like we're shouting into the void at this point. For details, I highly recommend going back to read some of those entries.

As of writing this, this thread is 26 pages long. Im not gonna read every post. That make me a bit lazy? Yeah, a bit. But if its an easy answer thats been answered ad nauseum, then put it in 2 sentences. If its so easy and solid a reasoning, I wont have much else to say.

HAVING ALTS HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH EXPLOITS, RAIDING, INVENTORY, OR ANY OTHER SO CALLED 'CHEAT' FOR MOST PEOPLE.

It really doesn't.

In the game as it is currently designed, you arent exploiting anything for the most part. However, my point was addressing "QoL" changes with CenterShock being the example - Changes which would bypass things like additional retainer services and how the game is designed around 1 PC. To implement these "QoL" features would make it ripe for exploit because frankly that is exactly what you see in other MMOs and you would see that here UNLESS they also redesigned a lot of how these features so you can have QoL changes as mentioned. My personal suspicions is that while a few people may have more honest reasons why they want said changes, the reality is that it would quickly become the norm to pay 15, make bank alts, and mail them all the overflow instead of buying retainers.

I have two characters. Both characters have 9 retainers (I am not afraid to pay for more inventory to keep myself organized). I could not care LESS about two more free retainers on alts. I could care less about raiding multiple times a week. I don't care about the blasted mogstation either. I simply buy what I want for BOTH characters if I like it enough to spend the money twice. I don't even care specifically about MSQ now that I can new game+.

My entire reason for having two characters is because I had an old, retired, main I decided to reinvent into a new character with a new name and a new backstory. Sonja is a completely different person from K'rina, and I enjoy the difference in their personalities as I play through the game. That's it. That's the reason. And I see no reason why I should have to spend a fortune in fantasia and name changes because I want to play something other than my kitty.

By that same token, K'rina IS my main character. She's wealthier and further along with things than Sonja is. Being able to craft things on K'rina to send to Sonja without having to beg an FC mate for help or commandeer the FC chest for a while, is not an unreasonable request, and honestly I don't get why you and a lot of other people are so against it.

Congrats on starting a new toon for RP reasons. But Ill bet the farm that youre a minority of a minority in this regards. You have an RP head canon for an alt that is different from your main. Even among RPers, this isnt that common a thing, and RPers dont make up the majority of the player base. Hell, we all have head canons, but most people dont want to start from scratch just to create a new head canon character that is only different in their own head and personal circle of friends.

That being said, again, the game is designed around the 1 PC system. They want you to buy name changes and fantasias. They want you to use the Mogstation services. That is part of their profit motive and the game is designed with that in mind. They give you the option to keep your progress and redesign if you want - OR you can buy the 15 a month sub and get alts where you can make the new "head canon". But the trade for that is you start from scratch. Which, by the sounds of your reasoning, is exactly what you personally want, so Im not sure what your investment in QoL changes is exactly.

Unless you think we're all cheaters and exploiters who should have our accounts banned because we have the gall to pay for more character slots, use them, and then ask that it be a little less of a pain to do so? Because that's the impression I'm getting from all this outrage.

Seems like youre taking this as a personal attack. Take a breather bud. Im not saying youre a cheater and need to be banned. My point is that if you design a system to be easily exploited in x fashion, it will be done that way by the player base at large in short time. Simply asking "Oh dont make alt characters that are just for storage" isnt effective, and good luck trying to prove people arent using alts simply for bank storage and not for "RP reasons" or "Leveling an alt". At least with the current design set up, it heavily discourages this aspect (capping on transferable money, using intermediaries for trading, not being able to use a common bank storage as a transfer point easily.) Not that they have eliminated it, just mitigated against it to make it not an easy to do thing.

Otherwise, some changes like being able to mail to alts, would result in bank alts and bypassing extra storage options they want you to buy. You see this in wow, you see this in other games, youll see it here too if some changes are made. Beyond that, the only reason Im seeing that you create alts for is for RP reasons, and even then, Im not sure what youre advocating for in regards to QoL changes that would justify making it more alt friendly that wouldnt open a can o worms and bypass mog station account features.

[Kytrin]

SNIP

Yeah okay, I'm clearly wasting my time, breath, and sanity here. I've tried explaining it over and over again, but it's like I'm shouting into the void. The ability to mail anything to my alt won't break things any worse than they already are, buuuuuuuuut it's obviously useless trying to explain that, so whatever. I'm out. Enjoy your victory. I'll let others take up the debate.

[JohnSpawnVFX]

Yeah okay, I'm clearly wasting my time, breath, and sanity here. I've tried explaining it over and over again, but it's like I'm shouting into the void. The ability to mail anything to my alt won't break things any worse than they already are, buuuuuuuuut it's obviously useless trying to explain that, so whatever. I'm out. Enjoy your victory. I'll let others take up the debate.

"It'd be nice to have it" doesn't excuse considering the consequences of what you're asking, whatever it is. More people here (or any suggestion thread for that matter) always harp on the benefits of what they want, without even giving a thought to the consequences.

How about "mailing stuff easily to your alts would make paying for extra retainers entirely redundant"? Ever heard of mule alts? Why does it matter that you wouldn't exploit it or playing the victim with "You must all think we're cheaters and exploiters!"? Do you speak for the whole playerbase? Why are you ignoring the fact that most players just follow the path of least resistance and abuse any non-disallowed exploit or loophole they can?

[Melichoir]

Yeah okay, I'm clearly wasting my time, breath, and sanity here. I've tried explaining it over and over again, but it's like I'm shouting into the void. The ability to mail anything to my alt won't break things any worse than they already are, buuuuuuuuut it's obviously useless trying to explain that, so whatever. I'm out. Enjoy your victory. I'll let others take up the debate.

Still havent really addressed my point. Im glad you want these things for your personal reasons, but youre ignoring the results of what youre advocating for when it comes to a broader picture. As an example, imagine if I advocated for the position that if I filed a report for botting, that instantly suspends a person's account until its reviewed by a GM. I swear I wouldnt abuse it, and it would probably cut down on botting! Frankly, however, you should know well enough that people will start using it in a fashion that would be toxic to the game, which will result in either the Devs reverting the feature or the GMs being so draconian that false reports will result in punihsment, which in turn means people wont report anything for fear of reprisal.

While Im not suggesting that mailing between alts is toxic, Im saying that just because you want something doesnt mean it wouldnt have detrimental effects.

To get what you want, without the 'abuses' Ive mentioned coming to pass, you would have to redesign a lot of the structures in how the game works. As an example, one structure they might do is simply make your retainers account wide. But then thatll hurt people who want alts that are completely separate of one another. And at that point, why is what they want less significant than what you want? Not to mention one shared inventory starts becoming a problem once you start having more than 1 alt if you so did choose.

Maybe take a break from the forums for a bit though. You got way too angry and personal about this. You want something in the game, be prepared to repeat yourself and defend your point, because people will have questions and comments. If its a solid point, people will back you. Im personally just not seeing a real justification here in the thread from what I have read(as well as a lot of quick dismissal of a very pertinent fact that the game is designed a certain way), and with the addition of more and more features, Im not seeing the appeal to having alts to begin with outside of very personal and limited uses (such as having a new character headcanon as you do).

[yukiiyuki]

Still havent really addressed my point. Im glad you want these things for your personal reasons, but youre ignoring the results of what youre advocating for when it comes to a broader picture. As an example, imagine if I advocated for the position that if I filed a report for botting, that instantly suspends a person's account until its reviewed by a GM. I swear I wouldnt abuse it, and it would probably cut down on botting! Frankly, however, you should know well enough that people will start using it in a fashion that would be toxic to the game, which will result in either the Devs reverting the feature or the GMs being so draconian that false reports will result in punihsment, which in turn means people wont report anything for fear of reprisal.

While Im not suggesting that mailing between alts is toxic, Im saying that just because you want something doesnt mean it wouldnt have detrimental effects.

To get what you want, without the 'abuses' Ive mentioned coming to pass, you would have to redesign a lot of the structures in how the game works. As an example, one structure they might do is simply make your retainers account wide. But then thatll hurt people who want alts that are completely separate of one another. And at that point, why is what they want less significant than what you want? Not to mention one shared inventory starts becoming a problem once you start having more than 1 alt if you so did choose.

Maybe take a break from the forums for a bit though. You got way too angry and personal about this. You want something in the game, be prepared to repeat yourself and defend your point, because people will have questions and comments. If its a solid point, people will back you. Im personally just not seeing a real justification here in the thread from what I have read(as well as a lot of quick dismissal of a very pertinent fact that the game is designed a certain way), and with the addition of more and more features, Im not seeing the appeal to having alts to begin with outside of very personal and limited uses (such as having a new character headcanon as you do).

Mailing between alts is toxic. Well man, if you came up with this sentence, it might be you who need to take a rest from forums.
I've played like 20 different MMOs through my life, but never seen any player base triggering so much to any criticism or just a wish to see improvements in system.
Like, come on, what's next, people will argue that server ticks is a cool thing and they shouldn't fix it?

[Melichoir]

Mailing between alts is toxic. Well man, if you came up with this sentence, it might be you who need to take a rest from forums.

While Im not suggesting that mailing between alts is toxic, Im saying that just because you want something doesnt mean it wouldnt have detrimental effects.

Hmm. Its almost like I said I wasnt suggesting it was, but trying to illustrate the point that sometimes what we advocate can have unintended consequencse.

I've played like 20 different MMOs through my life, but never seen any player base triggering so much to any criticism or just a wish to see improvements in system.
Like, come on, what's next, people will argue that server ticks is a cool thing and they shouldn't fix it?

No one is saying asking for improvements is bad. What I am suggesting is the consideration of what they want would also entail and isnt inline with the current structure of the game. This isnt WoW, and I dont mean that flippantly. How WoW is structured as a game is different than how FFXIV is from a PC standpoint, and the differences means that just because it works on WoW doesnt mean it would work here without issue or abuse.