Quote Originally Posted by Lyth View Post
Enmity management is not an intrinsic part of tanking. Human players in PvP games ignore enmity, and yet tanks still often exist in these games.

Tanking is about how you control the space around you and your team. It doesn't matter whether it's because the AI is told to attack you specifically (enmity) or because you represent a credible threat in being able to intercept/stun/punish a human player who tries to slip past you, so long as you have a means to control the fight.

Several adds spawn around the arena. The tanking 'test' is never about knowing what enmity buttons to press. It's about knowing when and where they pop up, and corralling them in the shortest period of time (ideally before they eat your healers).

The removal of the old stance system and enmity combos didn't take anything away from tanking that wasn't already lacking in raid design. As for the question of bloat, well, the majority of the buttons that you press in any MMO are bloat. Pressing several buttons when just one would suffice helps to soothe and reassure you that you're doing something skillful when you're grinding mind-numbing content ('look at how complex my rotation is, even though the decision-making never changes'). That's why some of the more mechanically complex genres out there have much fewer buttons (but are more positioning dependent).
Incorrect assertion from the get go. Enmity management is how you intercept and control. It's present in PvP, it just doesn't have a tangible/numerical value. It's the feeling you create by making your presence impactful, tilting the players you are against so that they will seek to remove you from play.

I can tell you right now that you are wrong again. Sometimes the tanking test was knowing which enmity button to press, since due to animation timing vs. enmity change registering, this could and did mean the difference between life and death. Example: Wyvern adds in Turn 13. If you didn't preload a hate combo, stage two of the combo, they were going to kill your WHM. If you used Butcher's Block the enmity didn't register until the animation was on the final swing, giving ample time for the Wyvern to dart to the healer and kill them.

The removal of the old enmity system removed the need to be mindful or contemplate such things as starting a fight with Overpower vs. Tomahawk. Don't be disingenuous.

Pressing multiple buttons takes more effort than pressing one, and it gives us more agency as players. If one button did everything that we needed to do, our hands would be less busy, and button wear would destroy both controllers and keyboards in a way that was irksome. It also wouldn't let us create these rotations that the devs find irksome, and later patch away from being practical to do.