"New game plus - quests will have no rewards..."

[Paladinleeds]

This is something I'll be looking into, and honestly, I'm glad it doesn't offer rewards. If it offered rewards, I would have considered not doing it at all because not everything needs to offer material rewards (and to offer rewards would have annoyed me). Honestly, I'm glad they did it this way. It means I can work on enjoying revisiting the story. ARR being absent has me raise an eyebrow though. Still, will be nice to revisit some of them. I'm of the mindset also that PvP should only offer PvP rewards. If it's something you enjoy, why not make that the idea behind doing it. I hate PvP. Despite how awesome of the Garo gear looks, I don't want to get it because I despise PvP. While for some things I get they need to offer the carrot to avoid complications for other players, this is about your personal journey. Therefore, it offering rewards of any kind seems silly when the whole point of it is to revisit old story.

[NessaWyvern]

I'm of the mindset also that PvP should only offer PvP rewards. If it's something you enjoy, why not make that the idea behind doing it. I hate PvP. Despite how awesome of the Garo gear looks, I don't want to get it because I despise PvP. While for some things I get they need to offer the carrot to avoid complications for other players, this is about your personal journey. Therefore, it offering rewards of any kind seems silly when the whole point of it is to revisit old story.

We used to have PvP rewards. Doing more PvP got you more abilities, stats, and gear that had morale to boost PvP damage.
But they removed it so it would be more acessable to new players. Apparently it was unfair for new PvPers to compete against those who worked hard for PvP rewards. Then they removed most abilities from PvP so it would be easier for new players to pick up. Then they added cosmetic non PvP rewards so more players would play it. PvP has already been completely ruined by squeenix so more PvErs would play it, but all that happened was that PvErs complained because, at the end of the day, they still hate it. Whilst making PvP completely unappealing for those who DO like PvP.