at this point I've been writing too much but i thought of something after reading exodus-e idea of giving ifrit a gap closer instead of the aoe.


The idea he provided is a really good idea and it build upon the quick agressiveness ifrit has being the essence of fire. I thought from that an idea of balancing the pets. The idea would work much better if the egi actions didn't exist and we had the old 15% chance to get ruin 4 procs.


Garuda:
We keep the aoe autos
We keep slipstream but we make the duration longer and the cooldown bigger bugging the potency accordingly
We make aerial slash be a dot make the cool downlonger and also adjust the potency
Enkindle remains the same
Devotion becomes a 10% magic dmg buff to all allies in the area

Ifrit
We keep the autos although they do need a buff currently
We keep crimson cyclone but make it have a lower cooldown
we replace flaming crush (that's the aoe i checked) with a gap closer that does the same damage as crimson cyclone with a bit bigger cooldown than it
Enkindle deals double the dmg on the first enemy
Devotion changes to 10% physical dmg to all allies

Titan
we buff the autos to be as much as ifrits
we make earthen armor able to be targeted and used on other players ( I'd prefer it to be instead of a shield a 5% dmg reduction)
instead of mountain buster we give him the old radiant shield effect aoe buff to all allies to do 50 potency dmg back if they get struck name is debatable
We buff the dot of enkindle to potentionally do more dmg than garudas enkindle
Devotion becomes 10% damage reduction to all allies

on single target
This way it would give incentive to use the big spells that garuda provides for a potency gain and even devotion if you got alot of magic dps swap to ifrit so he can go ham and then use titan to not only mitigate dmg from the tank or anyone else but also get a potentionaly good dmg depending how things are going and then swap back to ifrit to keep on the heat going.

on aoe
This way you could use garuda for aoe like now but if the tank could hold still titans actions would give an incentive to swap to him and then back to garuda and of course to ifrit when there is like one add


That's my thought at least i could be completely wrong ofc