Quote Originally Posted by Theodric View Post
If art is posted here, it can safely be critiqued. Especially if it's creepy and/or samey. Furthermore, some of it is objectively pushing the boundaries as to what is considered to be acceptable within polite society.
The function of critique is to improve the quality of something and only has real value if the creator(s) of the work or works is receiving said critique. Critique is also only really critique if it offers objective and actionable suggestions for improvement. You're not doing that. You're criticizing (different word here) work that other people than the original creators are posting to the forums by calling it "creepy." That is not critiquing. You also use the word "samey." What does that even mean? Do you want multiple different people to draw drastically different ideas of the same concept? Maybe they all think about it in similar ways. It's fanart of an existing idea based off of what we are being shown already. Again, "samey" is not good critique. You can't just say something is X without any explanation and call it critique.