Give the possible Eureka 5.X its own weapon, and separate Relic from it

[Reynhart]

It is purely an afterthought because they needed to toss the relic into something.

Come on, this, again ?

There is no reason we can't have more horizontal progression and choices.

There's no horizontal progression in this game, and adding another weapon would not be enough to change that as long as content is the same.

There is no reason there can't be a good weapon in raid, a good tome weapon, a good relic weapon, and a good eureka weapon.

Yes, the reason is that having several weapons based on the same concept means that one will be useless. And you forgot the Primal weapon.
On the other hand, if they do that, can you give me a reason why they shouldn't offer more option for just every other high level weapon ? Primal, Raid, Craft, etc...

No one should be against this thread or having /more/ content ( I understand believing it to be implausible but thats it ).

Well, since you literally ask for a weapon that reuses old content, you're not advocating for more content.