Crafting requirements.

[Adren]

Never heard of you, and I can't imagine your reputation being all that high up there considering your comment in the first quote of my post.

Your thread just sounds like some kind of post to speak for all the newer players, and how they'll just ignore crafting, simply because there's one small bump going from 50-51.
News flash: newer players are just as capable to figure out if they like crafting or not, before they reach even 50.

You don't even know WHO I am..... Who I am is currently is a contributor for one of the largest game review sites. If you've read any game reviews for upcoming or current MMOrpgs then most likely you've read one of my pieces. As for my reputation... Well we get feedback and if our feedback dips we make less money.

[Adren]

OP take a good look at the images below. Look long and hard at the lvl 50 4 star!! Hate to break it too you, but lvl 50 4 star gear is not worth it. One extra materia slot and One extra stat are not worth the time,effort and gil need to craft them to NQ or HQ or even try. That lvl 51 White is cheaper and eaiser to craft to NQ or HQ and can be done a lot quicker.

Crafting leve items to HQ while leveling is not easy and requires more then just slapping on HQ crafting gear. You need melds, overmelds, a good rotation along with food and medicine, other crafting classes have skills that make hitting HQ easier so leveling them is advised. You can craft HQ leves with the lvl 51 stuff but you will have to due what I just mentioned. Also getting 4 star AAR crafting gear or HW 2 star crafting gear now is pointless and waste of time!!


(Difficulty:586 Quality:5783) Control +29 cp +2 3- Materia slots



(Difficulty:421 Quality:4561) Control +30 2-Materia slots

Umm the artisan gear is better then the 50 4 star and easier to get IMO. The chest has 107 craft. 35 control and 2 CP, better then the 51 gear which has 92 craft and 30 control even HQ it's only 105/34. IF you don't have every craft at 51 already you wont over meld it. Since it's I level 65 the best you can meld into it is a 4. Even if you meld 4s the best you can get is 107....So the 50 greens are better then the 51s Unless you can manage to get HQ and even then you don't meet the recommended crafting stats for level 51 crafts....... There is no level 51 arm for crafting BTW so the best you're gonna do (without having to grind through hours of content that you're better off ignoring because you can level through it to 52 faster then grinding to get the 90 arms) is the artisan. Yes you can level past it really quickly which is my point the I level 90 stuff is a waste of time. So streamline it. It's pointless and most new people ignore it.

[MistakeNot]

So the 50 greens are better then the 51s

So?
The best level 50 combat gear (Augmented Ironworks) is a lot better than any of the level 51 stuff.
That is the case all over the line - the top-end gear at old level caps is a good deal better than the gear you can get at the next few levels. This is true for crafting, gathering, and battle gear.
This is fully intentional and in no way a problem.

[Nezerius]

You don't even know WHO I am..... Who I am is currently is a contributor for one of the largest game review sites.

Okay? Cool, I guess?

If you've read any game reviews for upcoming or current MMOrpgs then most likely you've read one of my pieces. As for my reputation... Well we get feedback and if our feedback dips we make less money.

I haven't, since I rarely read reviews, nor do I hop MMOs often. If I see one that's interesting to me, it's almost always while I'm checking random youtube videos.

So you're right, I have no idea who you are, but I stand by my comment in my initial post.

You're also missing the point of the lvl 50 4-star DoH gear. It was meant to be the endgame gear for crafters in 2.x, kinda like their "raid gear". The extra materia slot is significant, because it means you'll have less overmelding to worry about.
They made the 51 gear lower so the crafters that put in the effort to get their gear in ARR, can actually keep on going for a few levels, while newer players have a relatively easy alternative to get them to the next set.

[NanaWiloh]

Umm the artisan gear is better then the 50 4 star and easier to get IMO. The chest has 107 craft. 35 control and 2 CP, better then the 51 gear which has 92 craft and 30 control even HQ it's only 105/34. IF you don't have every craft at 51 already you wont over meld it. Since it's I level 65 the best you can meld into it is a 4. Even if you meld 4s the best you can get is 107....So the 50 greens are better then the 51s Unless you can manage to get HQ and even then you don't meet the recommended crafting stats for level 51 crafts....... There is no level 51 arm for crafting BTW so the best you're gonna do (without having to grind through hours of content that you're better off ignoring because you can level through it to 52 faster then grinding to get the 90 arms) is the artisan. Yes you can level past it really quickly which is my point the I level 90 stuff is a waste of time. So streamline it. It's pointless and most new people ignore it.

Alright my mistake on something here forgot there are two types of Artisan gear. Crafted and the one from the vendor :P The vendor one I would not bother with better stats or not, as the rng at trying to hit HQ on the items required for turn in could end up costing you Hundreds of thousands of gil. Then again getting Master book 2 at level 50 can cost same if your not lucky or lacking on leveling up all crafting classes. The 51 gear is pretty much aimed at players who didnt get the Artisan gear or started the game after ARR. Fieldcraft 3 demateria on my realm is going for 27k a piece and you need 2 of them to craft one turn in item. For most new players that is a lot of gil too just be tossing out there in the hopes of success on the first try.

As someone already pointed out once you hit level 53 or so on any crafter the gear you find is better then Artisan, that is without crafting to HQ or melding.

[Adren]

I see a lot of people commenting things like "once you hit 53 it's easier". Not arguing that. It's also part of what I'm saying. HW content is now considered leveling. It's no longer "end game" so it should have been streamlined and brought into line with the flow of ARR. There's this HUGE difficulty spike for people trying to level crafting 50-60 (ARR level 50 recommends 178. HW recommends 478). There is no point in going after the I level 90 gear when in 3 levels it's going to be useless but you almost NEED the I level 90 stuff to HQ level 50 leve items. When HW was "end game" that served a purpose. With SB it doesn't.

[Adren]

So?
The best level 50 combat gear (Augmented Ironworks) is a lot better than any of the level 51 stuff.
That is the case all over the line - the top-end gear at old level caps is a good deal better than the gear you can get at the next few levels. This is true for crafting, gathering, and battle gear.
This is fully intentional and in no way a problem.

Yes this is true but you cant get the I level 90 crafting as easily as you can the 120 ironworks. If crafting were streamlined like combat between ARR and HW as I'm suggesting then we wouldn't be having this conversation.

[NanaWiloh]

I see a lot of people commenting things like "once you hit 53 it's easier". Not arguing that. It's also part of what I'm saying. HW content is now considered leveling. It's no longer "end game" so it should have been streamlined and brought into line with the flow of ARR. There's this HUGE difficulty spike for people trying to level crafting 50-60 (ARR level 50 recommends 178. HW recommends 478). There is no point in going after the I level 90 gear when in 3 levels it's going to be useless but you almost NEED the I level 90 stuff to HQ level 50 leve items. When HW was "end game" that served a purpose. With SB it doesn't.

If they did streamline it, You would still need to the cross classes skills which means leveling up all crafters. At level 50 you dont have specialist ablities so hitting HQ on a level 50 leve without cross class skills becomes very hard. You have all crafters above 50 without even trying it out you should know how hard and frustrating it would be.

[Nezerius]

Yes this is true but you cant get the I level 90 crafting as easily as you can the 120 ironworks. If crafting were streamlined like combat between ARR and HW as I'm suggesting then we wouldn't be having this conversation.

Except it doesn't need streamlining. Lvl 50 players don't need to jump to lvl 51 recipes right away, there's lvl 50 ones to craft mats, needed to craft stuff past that. Use a crafting manual for bonus exp while doing so.
There's also GC turn ins, which will always be ARR recipes at 50 (and a few lvls after). Once they hit 51, they'll be at the recipe's lvl, making it so they no longer get that penalty on being lower than the recipe's lvl.

Also, you're probably focusing a bit too much on the Recommended stats. They're not a requirement, else the game wouldn't even allow the player to start the craft.

But you're probably gonna say that crafting to gain exp is somehow not fun for all these new players.

[ErryK]

OHHHH NOOOOO someone got their feels hurt cause someone insulted SE and has to rush to the defense of their favorite company!!!. Now you have to post about it!!!! Poor poor feels. Lol. Must be SOOOO hard living with such tender feels. Maybe if SE had used some logic then their half baked solution wouldn't have been necessary?

Get over yourself, my dude. It's just a recommendation. You don't need to make everything HQ, you've never been able to HQ stuff early on anyways without % chance, ie. Level 1 WVR with Level 1 gear HQing a Level 1 recipe is impossible unless RNG blesses you. On-level or not, doesn't matter, you're not doing it unless you got the skills/stats for it, whether that's higher or lower than the recommendation.