Quote Originally Posted by whiskeybravo View Post
Nowhere did I say it was OK for people to undergear content. Simple fact is, I rarely even bother to look at people's gear because, by and large, it's entirely irrelevant.
The rest of your post is irrelevant to my post, what you do, what you check, and what you "harass" has nothing to do with what I said. If a undergeared tank is "harassing" the group by making the healer's job too hard, and clearly by the op's story 272 fits that, it will be valid to kick them. You do realize the OP here is only one side of the story right?

Do I need to quote you again because you literally did say you are ok with people going under geared, and same reason why you seem to think 272 tanks in Castrum Abania in a pug setting seems to be fine. Not everyone is going to be fine with it, not every healer is going to be fine babysitting that.
Quote Originally Posted by whiskeybravo View Post
I haven't read every comment but the OP did not elaborate on their exact gear set, so everybody is just assuming worst case scenario?
I went into detail of that before, and that is honestly the OP's fault. They only wanted to come here to see if others where fine with 272 in Castrum Abania and the answer is no. The tank in question may very well be weaker then full augmented shire as well, who are you to assume the best case? The 270 argument was done exactly for this reason, it is something we can look at, stat totals and such, and it is the same comments I told with one poster talking about if 250 is ok for the first 2 dungeons and my answer is, depends on what the gear is.