Its ffxiv combat really so slow and boring?

[Sigma-Astra]

So you're against it on an assumption. There's nothing to balance. The game already works this way. Nothing about the rotations changes. All that changes is that 6+ buttons become 3. That's it.

Arguing that it works in PvP and that it should work flawlessly in PvE is a terrible argument.

PvP demolishes half of your toolkit and to be frank, you probably don't need it, but in places like EX trials, 24 man raids, and Savage? Yea, this could be a problem.

There's nothing in PvP that's entirely stressful that would require knowing your full rotation intuitively as opposed to actual PvE content where knowing and not knowing makes fundamental differences all around.

PvP is just not focused on in this game enough sadly.

It works in PvP because of what PvP is, it's not the same for PvE.