Quote Originally Posted by Reynhart View Post
Interesting ideas in this post. I'm mainly a fan of WS giving a cumulated shield. I've posted something similar a long time ago, which I'd like to call Barrier Per Second. This way, mastering your rotation would have a huge impact on your survival, and no tank could ever advocate to simply spamming RoH all the time.

The point that bothers me is the removal of the stances. Like I said, I think stances are a good thing to give a proper damage balance between tanks and DPS jobs while allowing us to kill things when playing solo. I personally love "turtle" tanking, but since "aggressive" tanking gained a lot of flavor throughout the years, it's more interesting to tweak the stances to give two options, each with pros and cons, be it for progression or farm.
Got tied up at work for a while - The idea would be that RA wouldn't generate much (if really any threat), but you'd have an on demand short combo mitigation generator you could use. You wouldn't be able to spam it nonstop:

1) It generates less Oath than other skills
2) It generates little (no threat)

It wouldn't be so much about mastering a rotation though, but about intelligent decision making and resource management.

With regards to stances, the concept of "turtle" tanking still would exist. It just wouldn't be a flat toggle like current stances. It'd be decision making points throughout the encounter than tended towards safety and mitigation rather than DPS. I.e. you'd prioritize RA over JoA (mitigation > dps) and you'd focus on converting your Oath into defensive skills and threat benefits rather than DPS. The idea would be that you could then react to the skillset of your teammates to cover any gaps. This concept is not handled very well in the current design.