Caster Changes in 4.2 (RIP Casters)

[RLofOBFL]

SMN needed a nerf. Plain and simple. It was doing more damage than SAMURAI in the 95 percentiles, being top dps. And it brought radiant shield/contagion & devotion. The BLM buff is going to add around 220 dps based on 95 percentile again. This will even out casters as is should be BLM > SMN > RDM, but will also most likely destroy SMN's already fragile place in any sort of meta.

On the other end they buffed MNK so much that it could replace MCH in the meta in triple melee friendly fights.

[HaroldSaxon]

SMN needed a nerf. Plain and simple. It was doing more damage than SAMURAI in the 95 percentiles, being top dps. And it brought radiant shield/contagion & devotion. The BLM buff is going to add around 220 dps based on 95 percentile again. This will even out casters as is should be BLM > SMN > RDM, but will also most likely destroy SMN's already fragile place in any sort of meta.

On the other end they buffed MNK so much that it could replace MCH in the meta in triple melee friendly fights.

SMN's personal damage on FFlogs included Radiant Shield, and was overestimated.

There's also some issues with their DoT's being overestimated according to Nemekh.

Bard/Ninja/Dragoon and Machinist were all better classes.

Feel free to checkout Blackcat's raid dps tool if you want more context

While you are correct it would even out casters, it also firmly makes sure no caster is anywhere near optimal.

[Shiroe]

..

agree, smn needed a slight nerf, either aoe OR st, but NOT both (so much...).., or others needed a buff

with a slight nerf, smn would have still had a spot in the prog meta, just not so much in the speedkill meta..., but like this in 4.2, smn will lose the prog spot it shared with rdm, .. and for sure lost any speedkill spot .. and its personal dps is now probably the lowest of all dps in neither prog nor speedkill metas..

now mnk traded places with smn.., mnk did need a tick more help to secure its prog spot, but now it just might replace mch.. if not nin too in speedkills ..

SE always fvcks up, when they buff AND nerf classes at the same time

next QA? pls ask Yoshi how he sees the classes balances (prog, speedkill etc), and ask him pls to ffffging elaborate in more than just one fffffing sentence..

he should write a book about class balancing.. (not a biography...)

[Tsurayu]

This will even out casters as is should be BLM > SMN > RDM

See, now that's the part that bugs me.

Where do we get this preconceived notion that one class should out perform the other?

I understand comparing personal damage, raid damage, utility, etc. However, this notion that the casters, or any other groups of similar classes, need to be ranked against each other in this infallible list just strikes me as odd, and part of the reason we are so up-in-arms over some of the most trivial changes to the classes. I feel like if we stop trying to come up with some ordered list to the value of our caster classes, we'd all fee a lot better about how and what we play.

I get it, we all want "our" class to be better, and we are guilty of wanting it to be the best, to out perform the others. It's such a cliched reasoning but - it's human nature. But the sooner we stop thinking that way, and stop trying to rank the casters, the better.

[CatStarPrime]

Where do we get this preconceived notion that one class should out perform the other?

From the tradition of "Final Fantasy" games.

I don't play BLM; but in my Squee-fangirl heart of hearts, I believe the Black Mage (played correctly, with elegance) should always be the "Biggest Gun in the Universe" - the profession which makes everyone go "OH STERCUS WE ARE GOING TO DIE!" when they enter a room, with dramatic theme music

Summoners are stereotypically "nicer" than Black Mages; they tend to not want to go for FULL POWAH, playing to empathy.

And so on

~From an average SMN

[VanilleFang]

From the tradition of "Final Fantasy" games.

I don't play BLM; but in my Squee-fangirl heart of hearts, I believe the Black Mage (played correctly, with elegance) should always be the "Biggest Gun in the Universe" - the profession which makes everyone go "OH STERCUS WE ARE GOING TO DIE!" when they enter a room, with dramatic theme music

Summoners are stereotypically "nicer" than Black Mages; they tend to not want to go for FULL POWAH, playing to empathy.

And so on

~From an average SMN

Eeh? Have we been playing the same games? As far as I am aware Summoners have always been the far more... explosive mage. Granted Summoners can be seen as "nicer" but they are far from weaker. FFIX springs to mind. Vivi is next to useless end game compared to Eiko and Garnet, or even Quina for that matter.

Though they may have always been generally weaker in ST throughout the series, their ability to take out multiple foes was rarely, if ever, matched.

[CatStarPrime]

Eeh? Have we been playing the same games? As far as I am aware Summoners have always been the far more... explosive mage.

It's been a long time since I played 9, but I know I never used Eiko or Garnet if I wasn't forced to do so. I would take Zidane, Steiner, Vivi, and backfill with Frey or Amarant

[blindfoldedkaos]

Snip

Because the way it goes is the more party utility you bring, the less DPS you bring. (that's been the golden rule with XIV)
Every job is supposed to have it's place.
for casters:
BLM are supposed to be the high dps job (that bring no party buffs, they just bring more damage)
SMN has a raise, and party utility in the forms of devotion and such, so in a perfect balanced world it shouldnt bring as much dps as the BLM but still be up there.
RDM is a two faced coin, it brings a bad heal and a raise, and it's dps by double cast, heal + raise + doublecast making able to pull raises out more (without factoring in MP) makes it slightly lower than SMN in damage.