Streamlining Warrior Stances

[Aana]

I think just making the 2 warrior stances into one toggle button would be fine.

Second. Theres no advantage in having 2 buttons and 3 stances (Defiance, Deliverance, Nothing) when the exact same effect would work with 1 button 2 stances.

Theres no 'skill' argument.

"Im in defiance. I want to be in deliverance now" : Hit 1 button
"Im in deliverance. I want to be in defiance now" : Hit 1 button.

Its just as 'skillful' as toggling grit.

You walk into a room. Theres 2 switches. 1 turns the lights on when turned up. The other turns the SAME lights off when its turned up and forces the other down. wtf. Just have 1 switch lol.

[Ekimmak]

Second. Theres no advantage in having 2 buttons and 3 stances (Defiance, Deliverance, Nothing) when the exact same effect would work with 1 button 2 stances.

Theres no 'skill' argument.

"Im in defiance. I want to be in deliverance now" : Hit 1 button
"Im in deliverance. I want to be in defiance now" : Hit 1 button.

Its just as 'skillful' as toggling grit.

You walk into a room. Theres 2 switches. 1 turns the lights on when turned up. The other turns the SAME lights off when its turned up and forces the other down. wtf. Just have 1 switch lol.

There's the advantage of not pissing off the DRK community any further by demanding more unneeded changes. Maybe after they get the patch-up they've been asking for since Stormblood's launch, then we can ask for QoL.

[Aana]

There's the advantage of not pissing off the DRK community any further by demanding more unneeded changes. Maybe after they get the patch-up they've been asking for since Stormblood's launch, then we can ask for QoL.

Don't be petty.

There's no 'line' for QOL requests. This isn't a 'War UP!! QQ' item while drks cast saltier earth in the corner. QOL should be supported for everyone on every class.

QoL=/=Balance.

[RamzaRuglia]

You walk into a room. Theres 2 switches. 1 turns the lights on when turned up. The other turns the SAME lights off when its turned up and forces the other down. wtf. Just have 1 switch lol.

This isn't the best analogy to use here. I know what you are saying, but 3 and 4-way switches are a thing depending on how that room is configured. (Sorry, Electrician by trade, so it stuck out.)

I am honestly more surprised all the tanks don't already have a single stance toggle after the button reduction. In PvP we already have it working that way (Though I haven't taken a DRK in PvP so not sure how that works for them). Long-term thinking we're eventually going to get more skills right? So, making room now would plausibly be useful for keeping bloat down across the board.

[Aana]

This isn't the best analogy to use here. I know what you are saying, but 3 and 4-way switches are a thing depending on how that room is configured. (Sorry, Electrician by trade, so it stuck out.)

I am honestly more surprised all the tanks don't already have a single stance toggle after the button reduction. In PvP we already have it working that way (Though I haven't taken a DRK in PvP so not sure how that works for them). Long-term thinking we're eventually going to get more skills right? So, making room now would plausibly be useful for keeping bloat down across the board.

Seconded on the PVP thing. I forgot about that. It works just fine there. The coding already exists. Copypasta prz. Drk works just like youd think. Grit. No grit. 1 button in PVP.

Lol yeah you 'can' do it, but multiple switches that work in concert are either to support 2 locations (kitchen switch when you walk in the door. Second switch for the same light leaving the kitchen 20 feet away), or they are 2 switches that are related but not the same creating a binary system. 2 switches=4 options. 0,0. 0,1. 1,0. 1,1. Maybe they are planning on giving us 4 stances to work with in the future like mudra combinations!!!! Patch 5.0. Defialiverance is coming! You heard it here 1st! :P

[RamzaRuglia]

Maybe they are planning on giving us 4 stances to work with in the future like mudra combinations!!!! Patch 5.0. Defialiverance is coming! You heard it here 1st! :P

Hybrid stances maybe? Lol

A "mudra style" tank would be interesting, like a rune knight that mixes and matches runes? That actually sounds interesting conceptually. When a 4th tank eventually gets released, who knows what kind of gimmick that SE would give that tank. That, however, is a different thread.