So, in my opinion, DPS issues can be addressed by simple math and crunching the numbers. Its a numeric deficit. There is an incongruency between DPS<=>Mana due to the latter's usage by defensive abilities, and an incongruency between Mana<=>Blood due to potency values and huge discrepancies in opportunity to dump and/or convert these resources, which makes fixing resource management a bit more involved. TBN is a big smoking gun here. I guess the reason I wanted to list them separately is because I believe one can be completely fixed without touching the other and vice versa. You could trim costs and returns across the board, remove effects from certain abilities and apply them to others, and lower the CD/effects of things like Delirium and make Resource management much more fun, active, and enjoyable without actually netting an overall DPS gain.
Basically DPS can be fixed by raising or lowering numbers (like potencies or costs, respectively), whereas resource management can be fixed by simply rearranging/redistributing numbers, if that makes any sense.
That being said you could obviously introduce changes that would fix both in the same fell swoop, but at this point I'm considering every possible avenue and layout of potential changes and how they could be implemented with minimal unforeseen consequences, and I think the distinction between DPS and resource management in that context is actually of considerable importance.
I don't think that we actually do, overall, considering the massive return of Blood Weapon. In 15s out of Grit with BW of spamming Syphon-Souleater we gain roughly 8500 mana, whereas in the same amount of time in Grit with BP and Syphons, we see something more like 5500 (roughly, again).
The additional mana from Grit-Syphon is only about 2/5ths of the overall gain from BW in a similar timeframe (BW/BP's 15s duration), which means that to be balanced in ST, BP would have to make up that remaining 3/5ths in the same window, which, HAhahaha... it isn't even remotely close to doing. In Heavensward, this is PRECISELY how it was balanced. If BP were brought up to about 720 mana per tick (rendering it equivalent to HW BP, about 1.5x a BW tick), then you would gain about 3600 mana in a 15s window, which combined with the 4800 mana from Grit Syphon, would equal out to about the gains from BW+Syphon out of Grit. Interestingly, without the buff to Syphon, HW BP didn't do this either. If you made BP proportionate to its HW values and also kept the SB Grit Syphon buff, THEN (and only then) our mana generation in Grit would be equivalent to our mana generation out of Grit. But obviously, SE has no idea how to balance this in AoE.
At this point I'm all for them just cutting the crap and making BP a vanilla refresh, which would instantaneously fix this problem, or perhaps applying the Mana return in much the same way as the Blood, where we get, say, 120 mana per instance of damage taken, and 500-600 per server tick. It honestly frustrates me in a very real, IRL sense to realize how obvious the solutions are to people PAYING for the game, but not to the people getting PAID for the game.
That being said, its a bad decision on SE's part as it robs them of a single controlled variable that is constant between stances. Any changes to Syphon or BW/BP or even Delirium now warrant an equal and opposing change to eachother which just opens up more points of failure or details that SE could miss when making adjustments (and miss them they almost assuredly will...)



Reply With Quote

