Results -9 to 0 of 108

Threaded View

  1. #13
    Player
    Chrono_Rising's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Posts
    922
    Character
    Gulvioir Muruc
    World
    Gilgamesh
    Main Class
    Dark Knight Lv 80
    Quote Originally Posted by SyzzleSpark View Post

    Back on topic...
    Cursory overview of core issues as I see them:


    *1. DPS
    ->Lowest sustained DPS, lowest burst DPS, no contribution to raid DPS, meaning having a DRK in your party is a 100% DPS loss assuming a given player can play WAR/PLD with an equal degree of skill or there is another player available that can do the same. Tank stance DPS is not a metric because it does not represent a measurable ceiling since sitting in tank stance for 100% of a fight (either by virtue of maintaining excessive mitigation that is not beneficial, or if mitigation is needed, by virtue of not utilizing swaps and thus giving both tanks equal DPS stance uptime) is essentially playing the job incorrectly, a situation around which we should not balance design decisions for any job or jobs, as that is how we got into this mess in the first place.

    *2. Utility
    ->TBN as a utility is undertuned and cannot be accounted for by healers anymore than Parry investment could have been in 3.x
    ->A party is simply missing a massive amount of raid mitigation in the absence of either PLD or WAR.
    ->Tertiary or personal utilities (things like having high mobility, extra stuns, gap closers, CC, extra AoE or ranged DPS potential, etc.) were largely eradicated as a balancing metric between the tanks with the introduction of the CR ability system and new skills like Onslaught, essentially amounting to a healthy dose of homogenization.

    3. Mitigation
    ->Reliance on defensive CDs tuned for spike damage to mitigate sustained damage.
    ->Piggy-backing off of the above, CDs are short in duration and mostly lengthy in recast.
    ->Mitigation outside of TBN is very poor, a symptom of balancing decisions intended to orbit TBN's design, which is problematic for reasons discussed in the resource management section.

    4. Resource Management
    ->Blood gauge is poorly balanced by everything costing 50 gauge and no less.
    ->Conversion from Blood to Mana is on a 120s CD whereas the reverse conversion is on a 15s and entangled with a primary mitigation tool in TBN, meaning the choice is typically already made for us on our resource management via this ability as per whatever the current mitigation needs are at a given moment. In essence, in order to effectively utilize TBN at most basic level, we need to A. Need the mitigation, B. Have a surplus of mana, and C. have a shortage of Blood, which is FAR too many checkboxes to mark off every 15 seconds.
    ->Mana has been cemented as a standardized DPS resource whilst still being used to pay for mitigation; no other tank has this problem, in fact very few jobs in general have this problem.
    ->Blood gauge consumption is never a greater gain than an equivalent consumption of Mana, and occasionally is a loss, making "not capping out" the sole motivation for dumping the resource at all. The logic of its usage is circular.

    *Mitigation and Resource Management are problems and are in many ways intertwined with DPS and Utility. However I have *'ed DPS and Utility due to these core issues representing a 100% loss to a group utilizing a DRK in lieu of either alternative, and therefore I believe these two areas are in the most dire need of addressing.

    This is a really good and on topic post, I agree that the first two issues are our biggest priority for fixing. From a design perspective I think that our resource management and dps are so closely tied that they could probably be combined into a single issue, but I can also see why you would list them separately for clarity.

    What do you think about us generating less mana in dps stance over grit?
    (2)
    Last edited by Chrono_Rising; 11-01-2017 at 09:27 AM.