Is the vote kick system improperly implemented for how it's actually being used?

[Yeol]

I have close to 7,000 duties on my main alone not counting my 5 fully leveled alts and I can say that people are rarely kicked in duty finder in my experience unless they AFK or DC. I would venture to say those who see a lot more kicks may in fact be the ones initiating the kicks or are talking about party finder and duties like clears for deltascape and the like where people join who have no clears or who are seriously under performing.

Agreed.

Even if you end up with a pre-made group in DF. They have no good reason to kick you.

I personally think kicking for different playstyle should not be allowed. It is getting abused a lot. SE should look into their policy and update it.