As someone who has played all 3, my thoughts are that if ANY of the magic DPS needs some love it's SMN.

However, even then I don't think any of them are so far gone that they can't be redeemed--all 3 are playable.

BLM should get some CD/damage buffs. It SHOULD be the highest magical damage dealer at the cost of utility.

RDM is just fine where it is, although I personally wouldn't mind a small (like 20 potency) Scatter buff.

SMN Bane should revert back to 3.x. Buff Misama/Bio potency by either extending time or actual damage dealt. Remove the damage scaling on Deathflare.


Just my 2 cents.