Change to Surecast

[AlphaSonic]

The problem is that there's too much competition for the other slots. Compared to DPS classes, healers have more mandatory cross class to take such as Protect, Lucid Dream (for MP), Swiftcast, Esuna (if the battle requires something to be dispelled). And then we have Largesse that is better than every other cross class we have and there's no choice at all. Most of the time we will pick the same. Probably Cleric for DPS increase but still.

[Gemina]

The problem is that there's too much competition for the other slots. Compared to DPS classes, healers have more mandatory cross class to take such as Protect, Lucid Dream (for MP), Swiftcast, Esuna (if the battle requires something to be dispelled). And then we have Largesse that is better than every other cross class we have and there's no choice at all. Most of the time we will pick the same. Probably Cleric for DPS increase but still.

We have to revaluate the current mandatory skills. WHM might not even need Protect, Cleric Stance, or Largesse, and Thin Air might be so good that even Lucid Dreaming might only be needed in fights that are going to be drawn out.

Currently for WHM, the only true cross skill they need is swiftcast. Eye4eye has a longer CD than SCH, and regen and medica 2 can still do their job without it. Virus is also weaker. Blizzard 2? Sure, if there is a DRK in the party preventing you from casting Holy. Situations requiring Surecast are few to the point of needless. Physick? We have Cure, which we hardly use anyway.

WHM actually seems to be in line to benefit the most because previously, it benefited the least from the cross class system. It's the other two healers I am worried about, particularly SCH since I don't play AST yet.

[VanilleFang]

snip

Blizz2, Physick, and Virus aren't role abilities for healers come SB. E4E is going to be that same across all healers.

So yeah, we only have what? 10 role abilities to pick from? A heavy, heal buff, protect, e4e, cleric stance, mp regen, esuna, Swiftcast, Surecast, and teleport allies?

Heavy is a niche pick.
Heal Buff is reliable.
Protect is only needed on one healer (good for 4man).
E4E is whatever.
Cleric Stance is bonus damage, but is god awful now. (+5% damage for 15 seconds on a 60 sec cd or something)
MP Regen is never bad.
Esuna is good to have regardless if it is required.
Swiftcast is OP.
Surecast is niche or useless.
Teleporting allies is either a niche or troll pick.

So pretty much you have Swiftcast, MP Regen, and Heal Buff for your first three since they are easily the most useful.

So no, WHM still benefits the least. We lost like 5 spells that we now have to give up role ability slots just to get back (protect, esuna, cleric stance, mp buff, mp regen), and we lost our heavy on Stone.

[Gemina]

Blizz2, Physick, and Virus aren't role abilities for healers come SB. E4E is going to be that same across all healers.

I know that. That comment represents the hear and now, and leads into the following statements I made.

So pretty much you have Swiftcast, MP Regen, and Heal Buff for your first three since they are easily the most useful.

Again, we DON'T know how useful these abilities will be for WHM come SBs release. Swiftcast will always remain mandatory because of our ability to raise, and it is just so useful in nearly every situation you can think of. It will never be OP so long as its CD duration remains the same. MP regen and heal buff may very well be situational since WHM has so much ogcd healing ability, and Thin air along with 60sec assize may very well negate the need for MP restoration.

So no, WHM still benefits the least. We lost like 5 spells that we now have to give up role ability slots just to get back (protect, esuna, cleric stance, mp buff, mp regen), and we lost our heavy on Stone.

5 spells we now have to give up role slots for? Cleric Stance (1), Protect (2), Divine Seal (3), Shroud of Saints (4). Am I missing any? We'll reduce it to three since Cleric Stance is now basically worthless until they buff it. Scratch out Protect as well (worse case scenario you cast it, and then exchange it for something else). You know have DS and SoS back (assuming you even need them), and along with Swiftcast leaves you with two open slots.

Too many peeps seeing the glass as half empty with WHM, when nothing was really taken from them. The only thing I feel was taken was Divine Seal solely for the reason because the other two healers already have/had abilities to increase their healing output. SCH retains both Fey Illumination AND Dissipation. Should we include Rouse as well? I can't speak for AST, but I do know that taking DS from us (A WHM specific ability!) was complete and total bullshit. I won't forgive the devs for that one. Fucking ever!

[Kaonis]

The problem is that there's too much competition for the other slots. Compared to DPS classes, healers have more mandatory cross class to take such as Protect, Lucid Dream (for MP), Swiftcast, Esuna (if the battle requires something to be dispelled). And then we have Largesse that is better than every other cross class we have and there's no choice at all. Most of the time we will pick the same. Probably Cleric for DPS increase but still.

Pretty much this.

It's one reason I am the least looking forward to leveling a healer. They have so many of their core abilities resold as cross class (with WHM obviously taking the worst hit of all, but that's another topic altogether). There's not much choice, and the slightest illusion of choice is things like Esuna, meaning you'll swap it out on a per fight basis, which sounds tedious and not fun. Somehow, in the process of trying to streamline their systems, they managed to bloat up the healers with trivial tedium.