Please remove the weekly lock out of stuff

[MomomiMomi]

Leveling is pretty different from gearing up at cap. Most people level, but very few raid.

Indeed they are. Leveling eventually comes to an end. Gearing doesn't stop. Two years after HW, and we've had weekly lockout the entire way. Run Dun Scaith once, got your drop? There's no more reason to run it.

Reached your tome cap? Tons of content becomes pointless to run.

Play multiple jobs? You can't fully gear them all.

Fatigue system, on the other hand, encouraged the playing of multiple jobs. It also wasn't a hard cap, it just made it incrementally less rewarding. Our lockouts are hard caps, though.

[Valkyrie_Lenneth]

Indeed they are. Leveling eventually comes to an end. Gearing doesn't stop. Two years after HW, and we've had weekly lockout the entire way. Run Dun Scaith once, got your drop? There's no more reason to run it.

Reached your tome cap? Tons of content becomes pointless to run.

Play multiple jobs? You can't fully gear them all.

Fatigue system, on the other hand, encouraged the playing of multiple jobs. It also wasn't a hard cap, it just made it incrementally less rewarding. Our lockouts are hard caps, though.

Fatigue did actually eventually reach a hard cap, where you would recieve 0 xp (or close enough to it that it became pointless to try gaining xp). And you could hit it on every class, in 1 or 2 days, and be unable to level at all for 4-5 days.

[MomomiMomi]

Fatigue did actually eventually reach a hard cap, where you would recieve 0 xp (or close enough to it that it became pointless to try gaining xp). And you could hit it on every class, in 1 or 2 days, and be unable to level at all for 4-5 days.

I'm not saying fatigue system was good. I'm saying this one is worse.

[HyoMinPark]

snip snip.

It works both ways, though.

Farmed Dun Scaith week one and got all the gear you wanted? Why run it anymore.

Geared all your jobs in Augmented Shire gear/Alexandrian gear within the first few weeks of release? Why run it anymore.

I know of individuals even with the lockouts in place that have multiple jobs completely geared out as much as they want them geared. And, forgive me if I'm mistaken, but didn't the fatigue system, at one point, prevent the gaining of ANY experience until the next reset? I feel like I read something about how experience was gained incrementally less and less until you just didn't gain any at all until the next reset. Again, I didn't play 1.0, so some clarification would be nice.

EDIT: Valkyrie gave me that clarification. Just posted it before I posted my comment. Thank you!

[basketofseals]

Indeed they are. Leveling eventually comes to an end. Gearing doesn't stop. Two years after HW, and we've had weekly lockout the entire way. Run Dun Scaith once, got your drop? There's no more reason to run it.

Reached your tome cap? Tons of content becomes pointless to run.

Play multiple jobs? You can't fully gear them all.

Fatigue system, on the other hand, encouraged the playing of multiple jobs. It also wasn't a hard cap, it just made it incrementally less rewarding. Our lockouts are hard caps, though.

Players don't need to be encouraged to play different jobs. Players already want to do that, and those that don't will detest the game for forcing them to do so. There's plenty of people who already have complaints about leveling other jobs for cross class skills, and so numerous are those complaints that they will in fact be removed completely from the expansion.

It reminds me of that time where Blizzard thought they needed to encourage people to explore the overworld, so they removed flying entirely from Draenor. What ended up happening is nobody ended up exploring at all. What would have happened instead is people would hit the fatigue cap on their chosen job, and then just put the game down until it reset. After realizing how much time they were wasting they'd probably just put it down and never pick it back up.

I'm not saying fatigue system was good. I'm saying this one is worse.

And I heavily disagree, and the player stats have shown that fatigue would have impacted far more players than the weekly tomestone cap does.

[MomomiMomi]

Players don't need to be encouraged to play different jobs.

Completely missing the point. What I'm saying is that even if you wanted to gear up multiple jobs to max, with the lockout system, you can only gear up one job. Doesn't matter how much you want to gear them all up. You get one max level piece of gear and you're done for the week. Or in the case of body/legs, one piece every other week. All your other jobs are left without.

The fatigue system, on the other hand, still let you play the other jobs once you reached the cap on one.

One system has a cap that affects all of your jobs at once, and the other system caps you on only one job at a time. The one that is only one job at a time is better.

[Valkyrie_Lenneth]

Completely missing the point. What I'm saying is that even if you wanted to, with the lockout system, you can only gear up one job. Doesn't matter how much you want to gear them all up. You get one max level piece of gear and you're done for the week. Or in the case of body/legs, one piece every other week. All your other jobs are left without.

The fatigue system, on the other hand, still let you play the other jobs once you reached the cap on one.

One system has a cap that affects all of your jobs at once, and the other system caps you on only one job at a time. The one that is only one job at a time is better.

I dunno, I managed to gear 4-5 jobs without much hassle, and I can take any of them into EX primals or savage. They don't all have to have 270 gear to be relevant. I ran out of stuff to spend tomes on actually...

[MomomiMomi]

I dunno, I managed to gear 4-5 jobs without much hassle, and I can take any of them into EX primals or savage. They don't all have to have 270 gear to be relevant. I ran out of stuff to spend tomes on actually...

At launch of the content?

[Bourne_Endeavor]

Without weekly caps, people will inevitably obtain every piece of gear they want within the first month. I cap nearly capped the 450 limit in a single day. It also completely trivializes any other form of gear progression since why wouldn't you farm Scriptures for the best gear available?

At launch of the content?

Not at launch, but it's not entirely difficult. The only content in the game where ilvl 270 matters is Savage. Since you'll always have two coffers per fight, provided no one else has cleared, you can simply ask your static if you can roll on other job gear you want. I geared Ninja completely through extra drops and the Scripture I no longer needed for Dragoon. When I got it to 60, it jumped to like 261 instantly. If you aren't doing Savage, well, don't worry about ilvl.

[Chalbee]

Completely missing the point. What I'm saying is that even if you wanted to, with the lockout system, you can only gear up one job.

Depends on what you mean by "geared up" currently I think you could consider yourself "geared up" if you are at least 260 on your main job and 250 on off-jobs. I've been able to gear up 3 jobs to 250+ and one to 265 solely through scrub content (tomes, sophia drops, kinna weapons, Dun Scaith, Alex normal) I imagine people who are actually good at this game probably have more jobs geared.